Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
This article is a POV-fork, per Wikipedia:Content forking. I shall be converting it to a redirect, per policy. |
90 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 6#This article is a POV-fork, per Wikipedia:Content forking. I shall be converting it to a redirect, per policy.
|
Random crap that was at the top of the page for some reason |
6 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#Random crap that was at the top of the page for some reason
|
for libdemplus |
3 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#for libdemplus
|
Gun Rights |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#Gun Rights
|
NPOV tag |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#NPOV tag
|
Fully Automatic Weapons |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#Fully Automatic Weapons
|
YOUR LOGIC IS FLAWED |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#YOUR LOGIC IS FLAWED
|
/* Gun control in Australia */ Marked unsourced statement contradicting main article as dubious |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#/* Gun control in Australia */ Marked unsourced statement contradicting main article as dubious
|
History of gun control in the US |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#History of gun control in the US
|
rewording problem |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#rewording problem
|
Dubious tag and unsupported "officially unproven" claim |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#Dubious tag and unsupported "officially unproven" claim
|
External links |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#External links
|
Do we need "citation needed" tags for this section? |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#Do we need "citation needed" tags for this section?
|
Essays about Gun Control |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#Essays about Gun Control
|
Check your sources |
5 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#Check your sources
|
Possible problem with a source |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#Possible problem with a source
|
British propaganda |
7 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#British propaganda
|
Jeff Snyder? |
5 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#Jeff Snyder?
|
The Bolsheviks |
5 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#The Bolsheviks
|
Civic duty. |
22 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#Civic duty.
|
Gun control in the United States POV Tag |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#Gun control in the United States POV Tag
|
Kristallnacht |
13 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#Kristallnacht
|
Statistics |
4 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 1#Statistics
|
Impact on Mortality and Injury - contentious text removed and pasted here for consensus |
3 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 2#Impact on Mortality and Injury - contentious text removed and pasted here for consensus
|
Rewriting this Article |
12 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 2#Rewriting this Article
|
Severe wording problems |
23 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 2#Severe wording problems
|
Impact on mortality and injury |
19 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 2#Impact on mortality and injury
|
Associations with authoritarianism |
17 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 2#Associations with authoritarianism
|
Dispute resolution |
9 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 2#Dispute resolution
|
Recent work |
3 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 2#Recent work
|
"Association with totalitarianism" |
29 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 2#"Association with totalitarianism"
|
RFC: Section on Association of Gun control with authoritarianism |
136 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 3#RFC: Section on Association of Gun control with authoritarianism
|
The Arizona Journal of International and Comparative Law |
14 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 3#The Arizona Journal of International and Comparative Law
|
close RFC |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 2#close RFC
|
Did somebody seriously say JPFO is not Fringe? |
33 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 3#Did somebody seriously say JPFO is not Fringe?
|
Reliable sources |
37 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 2#Reliable sources
|
Is Parker authoritative?? |
27 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 9#Is Parker authoritative??
|
Mainstream views |
5 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 3#Mainstream views
|
This article should cover the historical perspective. |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 3#This article should cover the historical perspective.
|
Stephen Halbrook |
70 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 4#Stephen Halbrook
|
Let's unsnarl this |
25 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 3#Let's unsnarl this
|
Changed title of "gun control in Nazi Germany." |
10 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 3#Changed title of "gun control in Nazi Germany."
|
General histories discussing nazi gun control (generally in relation to Kristallnacht) |
15 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 4#General histories discussing nazi gun control (generally in relation to Kristallnacht)
|
Definition of gun control in lead paragraph absurdly broad |
4 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 3#Definition of gun control in lead paragraph absurdly broad
|
First part of intro sentence |
6 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 3#First part of intro sentence
|
discussion moved from user talk |
13 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 4#discussion moved from user talk
|
proposed new section/paragraph on 3d printing and effect on gun control |
16 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 4#proposed new section/paragraph on 3d printing and effect on gun control
|
"Influence of Technology" section |
11 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 4#"Influence of Technology" section
|
Protection has expired |
44 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 4#Protection has expired
|
germany first sentence |
29 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 4#germany first sentence
|
Gun control in Bolshevist Russia sourced entirely to Russian sources |
25 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 5#Gun control in Bolshevist Russia sourced entirely to Russian sources
|
RFC |
159 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 5#RFC
|
Another thought on the articles... |
21 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 5#Another thought on the articles...
|
The RfC above has got nowhere: I propose it be closed as no consensus, and a second one opened. |
5 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 5#The RfC above has got nowhere: I propose it be closed as no consensus, and a second one opened.
|
GC v. GP |
58 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 6#GC v. GP
|
Keeping score |
90 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 6#Keeping score
|
Suggestion 2 |
27 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 6#Suggestion 2
|
Lets untangle the questions |
6 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 7#Lets untangle the questions
|
DR |
12 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 7#DR
|
Article protected |
22 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 7#Article protected
|
The night Raleigh died |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 7#The night Raleigh died
|
"Homicide" / fluid terms |
17 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 7#"Homicide" / fluid terms
|
Progress? |
26 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 14#Progress?
|
Authoritarianism and gun control RFC |
162 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 15#Authoritarianism and gun control RFC
|
Japan |
12 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 13#Japan
|
Neutral sources suggestion |
10 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 7#Neutral sources suggestion
|
Use of Peer Reviewed Sources |
52 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 7#Use of Peer Reviewed Sources
|
WP:GAME WP:DE |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 7#WP:GAME WP:DE
|
Peer Reviewed Law Journal as "unreliable" |
12 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 8#Peer Reviewed Law Journal as "unreliable"
|
Removed Bolshevik Russia, should we add a section on the UK |
3 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 7#Removed Bolshevik Russia, should we add a section on the UK
|
Article format and sections |
28 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 8#Article format and sections
|
Law journals and peer review |
18 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 8#Law journals and peer review
|
Guns and Germany, reboot |
32 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 7#Guns and Germany, reboot
|
Was this article ever any good? |
37 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 8#Was this article ever any good?
|
Remove duplication notice |
14 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 8#Remove duplication notice
|
References to Japanese section |
4 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 8#References to Japanese section
|
Sources |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 8#Sources
|
A good roadmap |
13 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 8#A good roadmap
|
Good faith forum to edit the content that was found contentious |
21 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 9#Good faith forum to edit the content that was found contentious
|
Article format and sections, continuation |
12 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 9#Article format and sections, continuation
|
Mikhail Kalashnikov obit |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 9#Mikhail Kalashnikov obit
|
One tiny piece of the recent back-and-forth |
5 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 9#One tiny piece of the recent back-and-forth
|
FTFY |
3 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 9#FTFY
|
Current warring would remove legitimacy from the results if it temporarily stands |
7 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 9#Current warring would remove legitimacy from the results if it temporarily stands
|
There is no consensus to simply erase a significant aspect of the gun control debate from this article |
90 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 10#There is no consensus to simply erase a significant aspect of the gun control debate from this article
|
On the applicability of WP:FRINGE and WP:NPOV to this content dispute |
128 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 11#On the applicability of WP:FRINGE and WP:NPOV to this content dispute
|
Straw poll |
5 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 11#Straw poll
|
Nonsense |
10 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 11#Nonsense
|
Good sense |
64 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 13#Good sense
|
Let's separate this |
10 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 11#Let's separate this
|
Edit Warring, Talk Page Use, Article Block and an Olive Branch |
66 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 12#Edit Warring, Talk Page Use, Article Block and an Olive Branch
|
Too many problems here |
61 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 12#Too many problems here
|
ANI notice |
4 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 7#ANI notice
|
POV-section Template |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 7#POV-section Template
|
reply to FiachraByrne |
7 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 13#reply to FiachraByrne
|
Current state of the article |
29 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 13#Current state of the article
|
Proposed text |
20 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 13#Proposed text
|
Proposal for moving on |
31 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 14#Proposal for moving on
|
Arbitration |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 13#Arbitration
|
Edit request |
3 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 13#Edit request
|
Edit Request |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 13#Edit Request 2
|
Citation for Bernard Harcourt and Robert Spitzer statement |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 13#Citation for Bernard Harcourt and Robert Spitzer statement
|
Edit request per BLP concern |
8 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 13#Edit request per BLP concern
|
When this article gets opened back up to edits... |
5 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 13#When this article gets opened back up to edits...
|
Article discussion |
21 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 14#Article discussion
|
Bryant and Spitzer |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 13#Bryant and Spitzer
|
Edit request |
5 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 13#Edit request 3
|
Nazis |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 13#Nazis
|
Nazi and Holocaust material in Gun politics in the United States article |
4 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 13#Nazi and Holocaust material in Gun politics in the United States article
|
Citing misleading information about sources: Harvard and "student-run" journals |
12 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 14#Citing misleading information about sources: Harvard and "student-run" journals
|
FYI |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 14#FYI
|
Suicide/homicide statistics |
13 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 14#Suicide/homicide statistics
|
3D printing citation overkill |
12 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 14#3D printing citation overkill
|
PP-padlock template |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 14#PP-padlock template
|
Gun Law in Nazi Germany, 1938 |
13 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 16#Gun Law in Nazi Germany, 1938
|
Studies, debate, and opinions |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 16#Studies, debate, and opinions
|
Notice of a discussion on the Gun politics in the U.S. talk page |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 16#Notice of a discussion on the Gun politics in the U.S. talk page
|
Edit request proposal: Remove Nazi material until ArbCom is over |
4 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 16#Edit request proposal: Remove Nazi material until ArbCom is over
|
Is this article meant to be unlocked now? |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 16#Is this article meant to be unlocked now?
|
Nazi Material |
78 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 16#Nazi Material
|
Gun Control as oppression |
11 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 16#Gun Control as oppression
|
Break in Nazi material discussion |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 16#Break in Nazi material discussion
|
NO gun control featured/mentioned in: Gun legislation in Germany, Adolf Hitler, The Holocaust, Nazi Germany |
40 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 16#NO gun control featured/mentioned in: Gun legislation in Germany, Adolf Hitler, The Holocaust, Nazi Germany
|
Terminology and context |
4 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 16#Terminology and context
|
This article stinks |
5 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 18#This article stinks
|
Re-ordering the paragraph |
15 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 17#Re-ordering the paragraph
|
International debate? |
40 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 18#International debate?
|
Misrepresentation of Harcourt |
4 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 17#Misrepresentation of Harcourt
|
Nazi gun control article |
12 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 17#Nazi gun control article
|
Edits without discussion |
31 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 17#Edits without discussion
|
Summarizing Harcourt |
6 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 17#Summarizing Harcourt
|
The paragraph, top to bottom, one point at a time |
10 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 17#The paragraph, top to bottom, one point at a time
|
Copying content |
15 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 17#Copying content
|
No more "meme," please |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 18#No more "meme," please
|
Plans |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 18#Plans
|
Nazis did not practice gun control |
45 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 18#Nazis did not practice gun control
|
query |
32 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 18#query
|
RFC is happening at US gun control article |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 18#RFC is happening at US gun control article
|
Notice of two related RfCs and request for participation |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 18#Notice of two related RfCs and request for participation
|
RFC regarding Nazis |
69 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#RFC regarding Nazis
|
United States |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 18#United States
|
Idiot question re "anchor" |
3 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 18#Idiot question re "anchor"
|
Nazi gun laws are not tyranny in the ancient Greek or founders' sense |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 18#Nazi gun laws are not tyranny in the ancient Greek or founders' sense
|
Sources that don't mention guns |
5 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 18#Sources that don't mention guns
|
Almost there |
17 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 18#Almost there
|
"This hypothesis is not supported by mainstream scholarship" |
5 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 19#"This hypothesis is not supported by mainstream scholarship"
|
RfC: Remove Nazi gun control argument? |
75 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 19#RfC: Remove Nazi gun control argument?
|
History section seems to duplicate Right to keep and bear arms |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 18#History section seems to duplicate Right to keep and bear arms
|
Notice of RfC and request for participation |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 18#Notice of RfC and request for participation
|
"In the context of this article".......Er? |
22 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 19#"In the context of this article".......Er?
|
Notice and request for participation |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 18#Notice and request for participation
|
First sentence of Terminology and Context section. |
8 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 19#First sentence of Terminology and Context section.
|
FWIW |
3 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#FWIW
|
Disarmament of black Americans |
7 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 19#Disarmament of black Americans
|
Evidence of efficacy |
7 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#Evidence of efficacy
|
3d printed guns section |
4 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#3d printed guns section
|
Semi-protected edit request on 21 June 2014 |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#Semi-protected edit request on 21 June 2014
|
International arms control info in this article |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#International arms control info in this article
|
Preserve international/arms control related material |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#Preserve international/arms control related material
|
Germany section |
12 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#Germany section
|
Miscategorisation of Research? |
3 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#Miscategorisation of Research?
|
Really? |
9 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#Really?
|
This article has been so censored that it should be deleted. |
8 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#This article has been so censored that it should be deleted.
|
Semi-protected edit request on 23 October 2014 |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#Semi-protected edit request on 23 October 2014
|
Gothean edits of 28Nov2014 need clarification |
4 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#Gothean edits of 28Nov2014 need clarification
|
Suicide and guns |
3 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#Suicide and guns
|
Semi-protected edit request on 3 March 2015 |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#Semi-protected edit request on 3 March 2015
|
Controlled by American gun lobby |
4 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#Controlled by American gun lobby
|
Semi-protected edit request on 18 April 2015 |
3 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#Semi-protected edit request on 18 April 2015
|
Semi-protected edit request on 4 October 2015 |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#Semi-protected edit request on 4 October 2015
|
Edit by Faceless Enemy 07OCT2015 David Hemenway |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#Edit by Faceless Enemy 07OCT2015 David Hemenway
|
One Perspective On Gun Control Debate |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#One Perspective On Gun Control Debate
|
Philosophy of law on gun control |
3 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#Philosophy of law on gun control
|
Studies & debates section |
4 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 20#Studies & debates section
|
lack of anchor/agenda |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#lack of anchor/agenda
|
Gun control is a legitimate term |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Gun control is a legitimate term
|
Semi-protected edit request on 7 February 2016 |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Semi-protected edit request on 7 February 2016
|
Semi-protected edit request on 8 March 2016 |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Semi-protected edit request on 8 March 2016
|
Nothing about the lobbyists/advocates for and against |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Nothing about the lobbyists/advocates for and against
|
2016 Lancet study |
3 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#2016 Lancet study
|
Lead |
6 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Lead
|
There's been several mass killings in Austrailia since Port Aurthor |
6 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#There's been several mass killings in Austrailia since Port Aurthor
|
Neutrality - lack of studies supporting the contrary points |
4 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Neutrality - lack of studies supporting the contrary points
|
Gun control referendums in 4 states |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Gun control referendums in 4 states
|
Semi-protected edit request on 7 January 2017 |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Semi-protected edit request on 7 January 2017
|
Mortality Rates in USA |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Mortality Rates in USA
|
External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#External links modified
|
Origin of the term? |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Origin of the term?
|
Name of this article |
7 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Name of this article
|
Requested move 18 February 2018 |
36 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Requested move 18 February 2018
|
Semi-protected edit request on 3 March 2018 |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Semi-protected edit request on 3 March 2018
|
Semi-protected edit request on 21 March 2018 |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Semi-protected edit request on 21 March 2018
|
Semi-protected edit request on 2 April 2018 |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Semi-protected edit request on 2 April 2018
|
2013 CDC Study Rand Study |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#2013 CDC Study Rand Study
|
Dana Loesch RfC |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Dana Loesch RfC
|
Adding Content : A Timeline to be specific |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Adding Content : A Timeline to be specific
|
Rough draft- gun control debate |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Rough draft- gun control debate
|
Semi-protected edit request on 30 October 2018 |
3 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Semi-protected edit request on 30 October 2018
|
Addition re. Canada with cherry picked facts |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Addition re. Canada with cherry picked facts
|
According to recent studies [which?'] |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#According to recent studies [which?']
|
Replying to your comment |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Replying to your comment
|
Citations -- The Atlantic |
3 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Citations -- The Atlantic
|
Studies -> United States |
3 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Studies -> United States
|
Why is there no History section? |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Why is there no History section?
|
Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment
|
Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment 2
|
Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment 3
|
Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
1 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment 4
|
Request edit |
2 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Request edit
|
Semi-protected edit request on 3 June 2022 |
4 |
Talk:Gun control/Archive 21#Semi-protected edit request on 3 June 2022
|
Draft:Sandy Hook Promise |
1 |
Talk:Gun control#Draft:Sandy Hook Promise
|
Request edit |
2 |
Talk:Gun control#Request edit
|
Wiki Education assignment: LLIB 1115 - Intro to Information Research |
1 |
Talk:Gun control#Wiki Education assignment: LLIB 1115 - Intro to Information Research
|
Wiki Education assignment: Equitable Futures - Internet Cultures and Open Access |
1 |
Talk:Gun control#Wiki Education assignment: Equitable Futures - Internet Cultures and Open Access
|