| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| categorization of this article and those related to it |
9 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#categorization of this article and those related to it
|
| Why I'm reverting the nationalist edits |
26 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#Why I'm reverting the nationalist edits
|
| "Greek" vs. "Hellenic" |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#"Greek" vs. "Hellenic"
|
| Oxford Classical Dictionary |
8 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#Oxford Classical Dictionary
|
| Berenike |
4 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#Berenike
|
| Hellenic controversy |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#Hellenic controversy
|
| Also... |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#Also...
|
| Don't you think you should have done this research before posing as an expert? |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#Don't you think you should have done this research before posing as an expert?
|
| M |
6 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#M
|
| Macedon language |
4 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#Macedon language
|
| Thucydides adds his Testimony |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#Thucydides adds his Testimony
|
| Macedonian language and it's connection with Greek |
4 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#Macedonian language and it's connection with Greek
|
| This article is biased |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#This article is biased
|
| Herodotus & Alexander the I |
8 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#Herodotus & Alexander the I
|
| Clean-up |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#Clean-up
|
| The falshification of Hishtory |
6 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#The falshification of Hishtory
|
| Get ready for Propaganda |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#Get ready for Propaganda
|
| Added 3rd paragraph, Expansion section |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#Added 3rd paragraph, Expansion section
|
| Arbitrary editing by "62.162.14.59" |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#Arbitrary editing by "62.162.14.59"
|
| the calendar |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#the calendar
|
| PROVE THAT U ARE NOT A VANDAL |
23 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 1#PROVE THAT U ARE NOT A VANDAL
|
| ancient macedon |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#ancient macedon
|
| the image |
9 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#the image
|
| Military |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Military
|
| Macedon as part of Greece |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Macedon as part of Greece
|
| Rewrite |
6 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Rewrite
|
| Disputed Content |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Disputed Content
|
| External links |
6 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#External links
|
| POLL: Introduction for Republic of Macedonia article |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#POLL: Introduction for Republic of Macedonia article
|
| Greek propaganda about Macedonia |
14 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Greek propaganda about Macedonia
|
| Addition/reversion of templates? |
8 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Addition/reversion of templates?
|
| Former Yugoslav Republic Of Macedonia or Republic Of Macedonia |
7 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Former Yugoslav Republic Of Macedonia or Republic Of Macedonia
|
| Deleted sentence |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Deleted sentence
|
| The Ordinary Name for the Ancient State is "Macedonia" |
11 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#The Ordinary Name for the Ancient State is "Macedonia"
|
| Neutrality |
6 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Neutrality
|
| Macedon today |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Macedon today
|
| What Macedonians probably were |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#What Macedonians probably were
|
| Split up? |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Split up?
|
| The map |
6 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#The map
|
| Infobox |
19 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Infobox
|
| Protected? |
7 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Protected?
|
| move, mergefrom? |
9 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#move, mergefrom?
|
| The Sun (and my unawareness of previous debates on it) |
13 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#The Sun (and my unawareness of previous debates on it)
|
| Diadochi |
4 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Diadochi
|
| Macedon project |
4 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Macedon project
|
| Please reinsert |
5 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Please reinsert
|
| The kingdom |
22 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#The kingdom
|
| Map |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Map
|
| Britannica Online |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Britannica Online
|
| Ref |
11 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Ref
|
| Please unlock page. |
7 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Please unlock page.
|
| South of present day Macedonia was part of the Macedon. |
18 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#South of present day Macedonia was part of the Macedon.
|
| Ancient Macedons were not considered "Greeks" by The Ancient Greeks. |
11 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Ancient Macedons were not considered "Greeks" by The Ancient Greeks.
|
| The way this article is being managed completely discredits Wikipedia |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#The way this article is being managed completely discredits Wikipedia
|
| Enough already. |
82 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Enough already.
|
| Referencing. |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Referencing.
|
| Macedon's Territory |
66 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Macedon's Territory
|
| Enough |
22 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Enough
|
| Upper Macedonia Pieria |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#Upper Macedonia Pieria
|
| poorly written article |
5 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 2#poorly written article
|
| name of article |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 3#name of article
|
| removed modern concepts |
4 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 3#removed modern concepts
|
| North of Greece |
14 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 3#North of Greece
|
| The Empire of Alexander the III |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 3#The Empire of Alexander the III
|
| Who says Macedon? |
18 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 3#Who says Macedon?
|
| Etymology -> "македнос", Solun, language etc?????? |
5 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 3#Etymology -> "македнос", Solun, language etc??????
|
| Prehistoric Macedonia |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 3#Prehistoric Macedonia
|
| Hat link |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 3#Hat link
|
| Article Revision: Description of the territory |
4 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 3#Article Revision: Description of the territory
|
| RFC on using "ancient Greek kingdom" instead of just "ancient kingdom" in the lead section |
127 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 14#RFC on using "ancient Greek kingdom" instead of just "ancient kingdom" in the lead section
|
| Macedonia Request for Comment |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 3#Macedonia Request for Comment
|
| Britannica's reference |
11 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 3#Britannica's reference
|
| ancient Greek kingdom |
32 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 3#ancient Greek kingdom
|
| Should Macedon be labelled as a "Greek" kingdom in the first sentence? |
86 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 4#Should Macedon be labelled as a "Greek" kingdom in the first sentence?
|
| Terminilogy |
34 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 4#Terminilogy
|
| Removed irrelevant diatribe |
5 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 4#Removed irrelevant diatribe
|
| Greek Peninsula? |
13 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 5#Greek Peninsula?
|
| albanian etymology of the name macedonia |
14 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 5#albanian etymology of the name macedonia
|
| Concensus among historians that Ancient Macedonians were a Greek tribe |
10 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 5#Concensus among historians that Ancient Macedonians were a Greek tribe
|
| Should Early History and Legend be further expanded, and corrected? |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 5#Should Early History and Legend be further expanded, and corrected?
|
| Alternative views: Meaning of the name Macedonia |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 5#Alternative views: Meaning of the name Macedonia
|
| typo in Macedonia (ancient kingdom) |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 5#typo in Macedonia (ancient kingdom)
|
| Coat of arms |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 5#Coat of arms
|
| Macedonia, power or largest and Herodotus on Greek Hellenicity |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 5#Macedonia, power or largest and Herodotus on Greek Hellenicity
|
| Greek word Makednos, meaning Tall Guy? |
12 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 5#Greek word Makednos, meaning Tall Guy?
|
| Edit request on 7 August 2013 |
14 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 5#Edit request on 7 August 2013
|
| Ancient Macedonians |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 5#Ancient Macedonians
|
| Request for comment |
5 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 7#Request for comment
|
| Ancient Greek Kingdom? |
15 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 5#Ancient Greek Kingdom?
|
| Greek Peninsula |
6 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 5#Greek Peninsula
|
| Ancient Greek Kingdom versus Ancient Kingdom |
12 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 6#Ancient Greek Kingdom versus Ancient Kingdom
|
| Request for Comment 2 |
71 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 7#Request for Comment 2
|
| Vandalism, unjustified removal of reliable sources, POV editing |
14 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 7#Vandalism, unjustified removal of reliable sources, POV editing
|
| Edit Warring |
43 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 7#Edit Warring
|
| REQUEST FOR A TRULY NEUTRAL CONSENSUS |
61 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 7#REQUEST FOR A TRULY NEUTRAL CONSENSUS
|
| Request for CONSENSUS |
5 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 7#Request for CONSENSUS
|
| Request for CONSENSUS which respects history, reliable sources and common sense |
38 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 7#Request for CONSENSUS which respects history, reliable sources and common sense
|
| A modest proposal |
60 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 8#A modest proposal
|
| Hold your (Greek) Horses! |
12 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 8#Hold your (Greek) Horses!
|
| Main content |
5 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 8#Main content
|
| Neutral Language |
12 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 8#Neutral Language
|
| Redirect of Macedon |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 8#Redirect of Macedon
|
| language |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 8#language
|
| "FYROM" |
4 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 8#"FYROM"
|
| Unintelligible sentence in lead |
30 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 9#Unintelligible sentence in lead
|
| Comment about "Greek" |
29 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 10#Comment about "Greek"
|
| Daric used as currency as well rather than simply one? |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 9#Daric used as currency as well rather than simply one?
|
| Ethnic Macedonian view |
4 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 9#Ethnic Macedonian view
|
| Repetitive use of the term 'North' in the lead |
30 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 9#Repetitive use of the term 'North' in the lead
|
| Essentialism |
7 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 9#Essentialism
|
| Greekness of the kingdom, again |
60 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 11#Greekness of the kingdom, again
|
| Proposal for solution |
23 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 12#Proposal for solution
|
| Legitimizing Wikipedia Vandalism by Illegitimate Voting |
11 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 12#Legitimizing Wikipedia Vandalism by Illegitimate Voting
|
| New sections on culture, society, technology, engineering, and currency |
43 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 12#New sections on culture, society, technology, engineering, and currency
|
| Unnecessary proliferation of photos |
6 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 12#Unnecessary proliferation of photos
|
| Gymnasium |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 12#Gymnasium
|
| "Institutions" section lacks sources, rewriting that, possibly the "History" section as well |
16 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 13#"Institutions" section lacks sources, rewriting that, possibly the "History" section as well
|
| Focus |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 13#Focus
|
| The article has been expanded and rewritten! Also: copyediting, article size, and potential GA candidacy |
5 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 13#The article has been expanded and rewritten! Also: copyediting, article size, and potential GA candidacy
|
| GA Review |
20 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 13#GA Review
|
| Thoughts |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 13#Thoughts
|
| Future plans: creating "History of the Kingdom of Macedonia" article |
6 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 15#Future plans: creating "History of the Kingdom of Macedonia" article
|
| Small error |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 13#Small error
|
| Brilliant work! |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 15#Brilliant work!
|
| Medieval icon removed |
22 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 15#Medieval icon removed
|
| Footnotes and stuff |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 15#Footnotes and stuff
|
| Seeking advice for moving material to split articles and summarizing it here, per WP:SIZE |
23 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 15#Seeking advice for moving material to split articles and summarizing it here, per WP:SIZE
|
| A quibble about the language section |
7 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 15#A quibble about the language section
|
| Featured article! |
8 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 15#Featured article!
|
| Split |
6 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 15#Split
|
| No to "southern Greeks" |
56 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 16#No to "southern Greeks"
|
| Macedonian empire-->Empire of Alexander the Great |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 16#Macedonian empire-->Empire of Alexander the Great
|
| See also |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 16#See also
|
| Getting rid of arbitrary wording, which may lead to supporting of the falsehood of Macedonians not being Greeks |
12 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 16#Getting rid of arbitrary wording, which may lead to supporting of the falsehood of Macedonians not being Greeks
|
| Taivo's continued protest |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 16#Taivo's continued protest
|
| SINCERE APOLOGIES |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 16#SINCERE APOLOGIES
|
| Question |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 16#Question
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 9 December 2018 |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 16#Semi-protected edit request on 9 December 2018
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 30 December 2018 |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 16#Semi-protected edit request on 30 December 2018
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 25 June 2019 |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 16#Semi-protected edit request on 25 June 2019
|
| The consensus stating the Macedon was not a Greek state was small |
23 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 17#The consensus stating the Macedon was not a Greek state was small
|
| Clarifying some facts about categorization's new name |
20 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 17#Clarifying some facts about categorization's new name
|
| "Macedonia(kingdom history)" listed at Redirects for discussion |
4 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 17#"Macedonia(kingdom history)" listed at Redirects for discussion
|
| Too Long tag |
6 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 17#Too Long tag
|
| Requested move 16 September 2021 |
10 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 17#Requested move 16 September 2021
|
| Periphery of Classical Greece |
4 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)#Periphery of Classical Greece
|
| About the foundation date |
3 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 17#About the foundation date
|
| Common languages listed in the infobox |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 17#Common languages listed in the infobox
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 24 June 2024 |
2 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)/Archive 17#Semi-protected edit request on 24 June 2024
|
| Ancestry of Macedonia |
1 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)#Ancestry of Macedonia
|
| Requested move 9 September 2024 |
21 |
Talk:Macedonia (ancient kingdom)#Requested move 9 September 2024
|