Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
...perished under the Soviets |
3 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 11
|
"Benjamin Valentino writes that mass killings strategies are chosen by Communists to economically dispossess large numbers of people." |
17 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 6
|
"Communist genocide", "Communist democide", "communist politicide" and "Communist mass killings" |
22 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 12
|
"Estimates on the number of deaths brought about by Soviet rule vary widely" |
12 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 7
|
"Large numbers of people were put to death during and after the suppression of revolts, such as the Kronstadt rebellion, the Tambov Rebellion and the August Uprising." |
9 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 7
|
"no communist country or governing body has ever been convicted of genocide" |
3 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 2
|
"Some" in the lead sentence |
6 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 5
|
"Suspected" Nazi collaborators |
7 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 2
|
"The influence of communist ideology in many of these events is disputed" |
7 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 18
|
??? |
32 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 18
|
1RR restriction |
2 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes
|
A "Terminology" section |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 10
|
A couple of comments |
5 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
A modest proposal |
3 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 2
|
A way forward |
30 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 18
|
Academic Analysis |
21 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 3
|
Academic and literary analyses |
7 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 4
|
AKA Aristocide |
41 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 2
|
Alleged Soviet assassinations |
12 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 3
|
And |
14 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 15
|
And II. |
11 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 15
|
Another lead variant |
2 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 9
|
Another move request |
46 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 15
|
Archive talk page!? |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 4
|
Archiving of ongoing RFC |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 2
|
Article discusses "excess preventable deaths" but is entitled "killings" |
28 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
Article length |
20 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 6
|
Articles for deletion policy |
8 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 2
|
Astor story |
37 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 7
|
Bad sourcing |
12 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 6
|
Balance |
33 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes
|
Basic Definitions |
4 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
Black Book |
17 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
Books Google sources |
15 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 3
|
Bottom line: What viewpoints have been peer-reviewed and established as the major view(s) of experts? |
33 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 19
|
Cambodia |
4 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 16
|
Capitalist Mass Killings |
70 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 5
|
Classicide? |
17 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 14
|
Cleanup template messages |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 17
|
Consensus building |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 7
|
content forking |
5 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 12
|
Continuing |
17 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 16
|
Conviction for genocide rather implies Mass killing - really! Even the UN definition says so! |
11 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 17
|
Crimes against humanity under communist regimes? |
20 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
Dead by starvation is still dead |
6 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 16
|
Definition of Communist (or communist) genocide |
22 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 1
|
Definition of Genocide |
7 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 4
|
Definitions of 'communist genocide' |
28 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 2
|
Deletion |
11 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 14
|
Deletion tag |
20 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 3
|
Deliberate starvation |
4 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
Denial |
7 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 12
|
Denial of communist genocide |
10 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 2
|
Denial of mass killings under communist regimes |
20 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 6
|
Deportations and famine are not mass killings |
27 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 5
|
Discussions of communist genocide |
10 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 1
|
Do not remove reliable sources that you don't like |
17 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 5
|
Do we really need a references in the lede? |
17 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
DPRK |
44 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 8
|
Edit warring |
4 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 6
|
Edits not agreeing with text |
6 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 3
|
Encyclopedia of Genocide |
3 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 1
|
Essay Template Message |
2 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 17
|
Estonia project |
3 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 3
|
Ethiopia |
17 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 1
|
Examples of synthesis |
24 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 18
|
excess preventable deaths |
6 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 12
|
''Explaining Postmodernism'' |
3 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 16
|
External links |
10 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 5
|
Followup to merge discussion/ possible rename |
26 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 2
|
For Fifelfoo - Black Book link |
5 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 4
|
Formal Mediation |
40 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 17
|
genocide |
19 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 12
|
Genocide of political groups |
12 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 12
|
George Watson |
119 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 15
|
Global Museum External link |
50 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 5
|
Goldhagen's book |
30 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 10
|
Hello, what's going on here? |
6 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 4
|
Inappropriate article's name |
24 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 7
|
Intro |
4 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 5
|
Is it anti-Russian propaganda? |
43 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 9
|
Is Nova Science Publishers a Vanity Press? |
8 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 5
|
Is this a school lesson |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 10
|
Israeli opinion |
11 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 1
|
Just communist regimes? |
50 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 18
|
Killed or deported |
6 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 10
|
Kulaks |
14 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 8
|
Lead section |
18 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 12
|
Lead sentence |
11 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 5
|
Lede |
57 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 8
|
Lede |
26 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 6
|
Lede |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
Lede again |
19 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 12
|
lede draft (dec 22) |
43 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 8
|
Lede etc. |
4 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 10
|
Let's get agreement on avoiding forks |
7 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 4
|
Link to POV website |
22 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 7
|
List article? |
17 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 6
|
Lost Literature of Socialism as a source - continued |
15 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 4
|
Lost Literature of Socialism as a source |
60 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 4
|
Mass killing |
6 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 7
|
Mass killings under Capitalist regimes |
15 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
Mass killings under Capitalist regimes |
4 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes
|
Mass killings under Communist regimes |
8 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 3
|
Mass killings under ''some'' Communist regimes? |
17 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 9
|
Massive Deletes |
21 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 6
|
Merging article |
4 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 2
|
More on Mao |
14 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 11
|
More Original Research shoe horned into this article |
12 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 16
|
More removal of reliable sources |
28 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 10
|
Move requested |
4 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
Need verification that ''Black Book of Communism'' is a fringe publication not accepted in the mainstream |
24 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes
|
Need verification that Rummel is not mainstream and possibly fringe |
45 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes
|
Neutrality Template Message |
17 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 17
|
New lead |
17 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 1
|
New proposal |
16 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 9
|
New title proposal |
11 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 2
|
No one of these scholars used specific terms to describe for Communist mass killings? |
18 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 11
|
No scholarly consensus |
3 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 10
|
No sources question this statement: see Valentino, Rummel, Fein, etc |
26 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
On the connection between mass killings, genocide, democide and ideology |
35 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 10
|
On Valentino and sources |
17 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 4
|
One more example of synthesis. |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 16
|
One step at a time: is current title good |
27 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 2
|
Ongoing attempts to put lipstick on the pig. |
29 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 12
|
Organization |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 6
|
Origins of Communist genocide theories |
16 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 10
|
Others |
6 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 5
|
People's Republic of Poland - again |
9 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 9
|
People's Republic of Poland |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 9
|
Personal attack |
3 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 7
|
Please Remove the "Red Terror" Section |
3 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 4
|
Proposal 1 |
11 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 11
|
Proposal 2 |
8 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 11
|
Proposal 3 |
8 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 11
|
Proposal for Formal Mediation |
3 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 18
|
Proposed Causes |
3 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 18
|
Proposed lead |
12 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 1
|
proposed sentence for lede |
18 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 10
|
Question regarding removal of all historical examples from an article |
19 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 6
|
Re-added materials |
30 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 7
|
Recent additions. |
7 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes
|
recent revert |
56 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
Red/Communist holocaust/genocide |
4 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
Reliable sources for lead |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 1
|
Reply to four sections set up to discuss templates |
90 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 17
|
Request for Administrator intervention regarding Termer's disruptive conduct escalated |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 6
|
Request for comments: Scope of the article |
38 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 14
|
Requested move |
32 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 2
|
Requested move |
16 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 14
|
Requested move II |
58 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 3
|
Review article of recent genocide historiography |
13 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 5
|
Revolutionary terror |
22 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 9
|
RfC: How should allegations that Ceausescu committed genocide be described? |
104 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 17
|
RFC: Miscellany in a thematic article dealing with cross cultural theorisation |
13 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 6
|
Romania section deleted by anon editor |
39 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 16
|
Rummel's three paragraphs and Transaction Press |
22 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 10
|
Scholarly sources |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 11
|
Self-contradictory |
6 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 7
|
Serious editors are doing a lot of work to fix an article that is, by its nature, impossible to fix. |
9 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 10
|
Should we try again to just delete the article? |
62 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 9
|
Significance of mass killings debate |
36 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 11
|
Smallbone's edits |
8 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 3
|
So what is the way to proceed? |
21 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 9
|
Some more sources |
23 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 1
|
Sources that failed verification or acceptable sourcing standards for their claims |
29 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 3
|
Soviet serial killers |
2 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 3
|
Specific concerns with the article |
65 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 19
|
Spelling |
4 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 12
|
Split this article |
3 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 1
|
Stalin's Labour Work Camps |
22 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 4
|
Strong request |
3 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 11
|
Synthesis |
52 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 18
|
Synthesis Template Message |
2 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 17
|
Table |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
Tags stay |
42 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 18
|
Template |
60 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 18
|
Terminology section. |
31 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 18
|
Terminology section |
15 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 14
|
The debate has died: Time for action |
40 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 19
|
The Evils of Communism and the Virtues of Capitalism |
4 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 9
|
The Great Leap Forward |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 11
|
The Great Leap Forward |
3 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 14
|
The lead |
57 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 14
|
The worst instances of bias or synthesis |
31 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 14
|
Think before you revert |
7 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 4
|
Third move option |
29 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 15
|
Third opinion requested |
Unknown |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 2
|
This article needs a new title |
18 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
TO DO |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 12
|
To throw another spanner in the works |
10 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 6
|
Unexplained category |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 12
|
Unlocked |
14 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 11
|
US congress reference |
6 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
Usage of the term "Communist genocide" |
20 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 1
|
Uselessness of the "expert" tag |
2 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 3
|
Valentino's book should be cited correctly |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 13
|
Valentino's typology in Final Solutions |
17 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 7
|
We've left out one very big category |
38 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 16
|
Weasel |
1 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 5
|
Well... |
11 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 12
|
<s>Were</s> Where We Currently Stand |
91 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 19
|
Why not? |
49 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 16
|
WP:PSRP |
10 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 3
|
Yet more literature review |
2 |
Talk:Mass killings under Communist regimes/Archive 5
|