User:Geogre/IRC considered

Please help out. If I've missed any major advantages or disadvantages, let me know via the talk page, or just add them.

{From: User:Jimbo Wales/Statement of principles.)

1.

Wikipedia's success to date is entirely a function of our open community. This community will continue to live and breathe and grow only so long as those of us who participate in it continue to Do The Right Thing. Doing The Right Thing takes many forms, but perhaps most central is the preservation of our shared vision for the NPOV and for a culture of thoughtful, diplomatic honesty.

2.

Newcomers are always to be welcomed. There must be no cabal, there must be no elites, there must be no hierarchy or structure which gets in the way of this openness to newcomers. Any security measures to be implemented to protect the community against real vandals (and there are real vandals, who are already starting to affect us), should be implemented on the model of "strict scrutiny".

Before we consider the best practices for the use of IRC channels associated with Wikipedia, we would do well to consider the limitations and possibilities inherent in the medium of IRC.