The result was delete. The discussion is mainly about whether the presumed notability conferred by general officer rank (per WP:SOLDIER) outweighs the argument that this is (more or less uncontestedly) otherwise a WP:BLP1E article. Opinions about this are roughly divided. WP:SOLDIER is an essay, and as such does not represent community consensus. I must therefore weigh arguments based (essentially only) on that essay much less than those based on WP:BLP, a policy. This means we have consensus to delete the article. Sandstein 08:28, 22 August 2015 (UTC)