Wikipedia:Requests for comment/User conduct/Archive 3

Archive 1Archive 2Archive 3Archive 4Archive 5→Archive 8
Threeafterthree 15 Dec 2007 Incivility. Toyalla, Binky The WonderSkull Threeafterthree apologized for any offense caused; RFC removed after a month of inactivity.
Gump 13 Dec 2007 Incivility and disruptive editing relating to Rob Bell article. Lyonscc, Virgil Vaduva RfC removed after inactive for over a month with no clear resolution.
COGDEN 12 Dec 2007 COGDEN has been editing policy pages in a disruptive fashion over a period of several months. Dreadstar, Slrubenstein COGDEN is editing in good faith, but perhaps inappropriately, COGDEN reduced contentious editing on policy pages.
Angie Y. 2 11 Dec 2007 "Inserting POV and OR material into articles despite several warnings." Someguy0830, Codelyoko193 Angie to be mentored by Interrobang²
KmWeber 2 11 Dec 2007 User repeatedly using a copy-and-paste unwarranted 'oppose' comment at all self-nominated RfAs. Carl (CBM), Mr.Z-man Consensus appears to favor no action by the community at this time.
Quantumentanglement 16 Dec 2007 Problems with WP:FRINGE issues and wikilawyering. The Evil Spartan, MrWhich Quantumentanglement has been blocked indefinitely.
Bruce1333 8 Dec 2007 POV pushing on articles; disruption Master of Puppets, Kablammo Moot; Bruce1333 indef blocked by Ryulong on 08:30 UTC 2007-12-09
MONGO 3 16 Nov 2007 "a persistent pattern of disruptive editing and personal attacks regarding the "Attack Sites" issue" Alecmconroy, Viridae ArbCom was unwilling to take case, RfC died for lack of interest
EJ220 11 Nov 2007 WP:NPOV, WP:V. Southern Texas, Malik Shabazz EJ220 indefblocked for vandalism.
Billy Hathorn 10 Nov 2007 "Creation of prodigious numbers of non-notable biographies, longest deleted articles log I can recall seeing." JzG, DGG Billy never responded, some discussion at User talk:Billy Hathorn.
Anonimu 27 Oct 2007 POV pushing on articles; disruption; incivility Biruitorul, K. Lastochka Moot; Anonimu indef blocked by Maxim on 02:08 UTC 2007-11-27 and by ArbCom case for a year on 17:20 UTC 2007-12-13
Scipo 19 Oct 2007 Edit-warring, incivility. Wyatt Riot, twsx Scipo indef blocked for sockpuppetry and block evasion (SSP report).
Angel David 19 Oct 2007 POV pushing. First Certifier, Second certifier Delisted due to inactivity with no clear outcome; Walton One and Yamakiri indicated a willingness to mentor Angel David.
Camptown 16 Oct 2007 Adding false information and removing sourced text. Liftarn, panda Delisted due to inactivity.
Geoeg 16 Oct 2007 Disruptive SPA. EdJohnston, Bfigura Geoeg indef blocked by Spartaz (see WP:AN/I discussion).
Sm565 16 Oct 2007 Edit-warring SPA. OrangeMarlin, Skinwalker User indef blocked by Moreschi (log).
Shamir1 16 Oct 2007 Reverting against consensus, disruption. tariqabjotu , okedem Delisted due to inactivity.
Duke53 12 Oct 2007 Incivility, edit warring, POV pushing. alanyst, Masamage Delisted due to inactivity.
Mattisse 2 5 Oct 2007 Edits regarding Drapetomania article. Cyborg Ninja, Malik Shabazz Delisted due to inactivity.
Gavin.collins 4 Oct 2007 Several policy/guideline violations. Turlo_Lomon, SamBC Initially closed due to inactivity. Reopened for admin action, but reclosed due to invalid reasoning, and lack of recent evidence to indicate dispute is still ongoing.
Luisosio 1 Oct 2007 Civility, original research, ownership, POV-pushing. Cleduc, CJLL_Wright Luisosio stopped editing on 9 October 2007.
John Foxe 10 Sep 2007 WP:OWN, WP:NPOV on First Vision article. 74s181 , wrp103 Delisted due to inactivity; discussion continued at Talk:First Vision.
Kmweber 3 Aug 2007 Rude posting in RfAs No outcome, discussion at standstill, opinions are against blocking
NE2 3 21 Oct 2007 Implementing the removal of "decommissioned" without consensus. Rschen7754, Mitchazenia MedCab resolved this issue (mainly content)
Durova 23 Nov 2007 Violation of WP:BLOCK, WP:AGF; request for admin recall. Physchim62, Lsi john Durova has resigned her administrative privileges.
Whig 10 Oct 2007 Repeated violations of WP:GAME, WP:AGF, WP:CIVIL as well as violations of WP:CANVASS and WP:3RR. Adam Cuerden, Wikidudeman Whig has been blocked indefinitely.
Alkivar 27 Jul 2007 Uncivil, misuse of admin position. Videmus Omnia, Rlest Arbitration
Tony Sidaway 4 4 Oct 2007 WP:CIV WP:NPA Viridae, David Levy "Matter was deemed resolved"
Nescio 2 13 Sep 2007 WP:GAME, WP:OWN, WP:OR/WP:SYN, WP:CON Ipankonin, Balloonman Delisted due to inactivity.
Ludovicapipa 6 Sep 2007 WP:OR, WP:NPOV/WP:FRINGE, WP:RS, WP:V Dalillama, KieferSkunk Delisted due to inactivity.
Italiavivi 2 Sep 2007 Disruptive editing Hu12, Zsero Italiavivi stopped editing on 11 September 2007.
Kwork 26 Aug 2007 Disregarding core policies, POV pushing Sethie, Reneeholle Kwork indefinitely blocked for disruption on 27 October 2007.
Commodore Sloat 24 Aug 2007 WP:NPA WP:AGF Bigglove, Isarig Apology offered and accepted; Proposed suggestions if further issues: dual mentorship for CSloat or ArbCom for multiple involved Editors
Chrisjnelson 19 Aug 2007 WP:CIV, WP:NPA, WP:OWN, WP:EDITWAR Jmfangio, Morgan Wick Proceeded to arbitration
DreamGuy 2 7 Aug 2007 WP:CIV, WP:OWN, WP:AGF, WP:NPA Dicklyon, Clpo13 Gone to arbitration
NE2 (Second RFC) 2 Aug 2007 WP:CONS, WP:WL, WP:NOT#BURO, WP:POINT, WP:FUC, WP:CANVASS O, Master son Issues settled.
Artaxerex 31 Jul 2007 WP:NPA, Wikipedia:Civility, Wikipedia:Sock puppetry, WP:NPOV, WP:NOR, WP:EW, WP:BATTLE Shervink, SG Request for arbitration filed here.
Ryulong 30 Jul 2007 WP:BLOCK. The Evil Spartan, Videmus Omnia User cautioned.
Peter morrell 20 Jul 2007 Incivility, personal attacks, NPOV violations Adam Cuerden, Orangemarlin Removed after Cuerden failed to sign in the right place; Morrell apologized
Jeffrey O. Gustafson 10 Jul 2007 WP:CIVIL, WP:CSD, WP:NPA, WP:ADMIN Black Falcon, Drewcifer3000 Proceeded to arbitration
Banno 8 Jul 2007 WP:BLOCK Orangemarlin, Jim62sch Apology issued.
Spartaz 7 Jul 2007 WP:BLOCK Pyrope, Readro Action affirmed.
Angie Y. 5 Jul 2007 WP:CIV, WP:NPA, WP:AGF and WP:CANVASS Seraphim Whipp, Bignole User appears to have changed her behavior.
Alansohn 28 Jun 2007 Wikilawyering, WP:POINT, WP:AGF, WP:NPA Eusebeus, Thewinchester Orginally closed on 14 August 2007, the RfC was re-closed again on 27 May 2008 due to the closure of Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Footnoted quotes which placed Alansohn on a editing restriction for one year.
NE2 22 Jun 2007 Mainly WP:CONS vishwin60, JohnnyAlbert10 Disputes resolved
Assault11 11 Jun 2007 Disruptive editing Cydevil38, Nlu No apparent resolution; stalled with closure of Wikipedia:Requests for mediation/Goguryeo for similar inactivity
Rhode Island Red 9 Jun 2007 WP:NPA, WP:CIV and WP:OWN at Juice Plus Elonka, Matthew User agreed to take a break from editing the article
Mike18xx 6 Jun 2007 WP:MEAT, WP:NPA and other subsequent issues. FayssalF, Proabivouac User agreed to stop recruiting off-wiki meatpuppets
Atabek 7 Jun 2007 Continued false accusations, harassment, and canvassing Hajji Piruz, Tariqabjotu Proceeded to arbitration
Bishonen 2 5 Jun 2007 accused of making false charge of harassment; accused of inappropriate block Ferrylodge, LCP Unanimous rejection of assertions made, with the only exceptions being the persons bringing Rfc.
Martinphi 1 Apr 2007 edit warring, pov-pushing and -forking, spamming, making use of meat puppets, abusing Wikipedia processes to game the system Simoes, Minderbinder No changes; proceeding to arbitration: Paranormal, Martinphi-ScienceApologist.
Tezza1 12 Mar 2007 Disruptive editing, WP:DE, WP:TE, WP:N, WP:POINT, WP:CIVIL, WP:NPOV, WP:COI RPWebslave, The Null Device Proceeded to mediation
KazakhPol 12 Feb 2007 personal attacks, edit warring, calling editors vandals, inserting the word "terrorist" inappropriately into articles about Islamic groups, inappropriate tagging. User:cs, User:Aaliyah Stevens
Logicus 1 February 2007 Repeated disruptive editing involving original research on articles related to the History of Science. SteveMcCluskey, ragesoss Delisted due to inactivity.
Trödel 25 Jan 2007 Abuse of blocking policy. TheGreenFaerae, Viridae Trödel apologized for misuse of blocking and agreed to never block TheGreenFaerae again, though reserves the right to request another administrator to blcok him.
Yamla 30 Jan 2007 Use of blocking to win content disputes. Justen, Mr. Vitale, 71Demon No changes.
Sir Nicholas de Mimsy-Porpington 2 18 Feb 2007 Improper closing of AfDs. Balancer, Golden Wattle No conclusion, though noted at time of close that Nick had stopped closing AfDs.
Jimmuldrow 18 Feb 2007 Discussing edits; abiding by consensus; assuming good faith; neutrality; original research. Hydriotaphia, Ferrylodge Although nothing conclusively resolved, all parties seem to be willing to move forward productively; closed per agreement
Essjay 2 Mar 2007 Community Trust issues over fake PHDs, and using them in advantage of content disputes Community certified Closed as Essjay since left the project
Hildanknight 30 Jan 2007 Self-filed RfC over "controversial" edits Hildanknight, no second certifier User opened an ER at Wikipedia:Editor review/Hildanknight as suggested.
StuRat 2 9 Jan 2007 Incivility, use of "deletionist" as pejorative term. TenOfAllTrades, David D. No additional complaints were registered for an extended period of time, and the dispute appears to have stopped.
Raspor 3 Jan 2007 "violating WP:NPA, WP:NOT, WP:3RR while dismissing policies governing article content." FeloniousMonk, Ec5618 Account was indefblocked on 18 January 2007 by SlimVirgin and editor was community banned (WP:AN/I discussion).
Suemcp 1 Jan 2007 Edit-warring, incivility, WP:V, WP:RS WP:NPOV and WP:OR violations. Dina, Slp1 Dispute stopped as Suemcp has been inactive since January 9 2007.