Wikipedia:WikiProject Ships/AFD

Shortcut


The following articles within the scope of the project have been nominated for deletion at WP:AFD. The results of the discussions were as follows.

Date Article Result
17 February 2005 HMS Jersey (P295) Keep
20 February 2005 HMS Hermione Keep
14 September 2005 HMS Onyx Redirect as duplicate of HMS Onyx (S21). Later created as a shipindex page.
14 September 2005 HMS Plymouth Redirect as duplicate of HMS Plymouth (F126). Later created as a shipindex page.
3 October 2005 Victoria Star 2 No consensus
18 October 2005 CS Salamis Glory Keep
19 October 2005 Carnival Glory Delete as non-encyclopedic. New article created 2 February 2006.
5 November 2005 USS Sproston (DD-577) Keep
13 November 2005 HMS Duke of Edinburgh Keep
5 January 2006 List of LSTs Keep
4 February 2006 Flying submarine Keep
27 April 2006 Schooner Jenny Keep
12 May 2006 USNS Stalwart (T-AGOS-1) Keep
26 May 2006 USS Wheatland (AKA-85) Speedy Keep (Bad faith nomination)
9 July 2006 HMS Kirkliston (M1157) Nomination withdrawn
13 October 2006 List of ship launches in 1946 Delete, but later recreated per discussion at WP level
5 November 2006 SS Timothy Bloodworth No consensus
25 January 2007 Proteus (WAM-V) Keep
11 April 2007 List of Austrian sail frigates Keep (later boldly merged/redirected}
25 May 2007 MV Vikartindur Keep
27 May 2007 HMS Hornet Keep
12 June 2007 Battlecarrier Delete as a non-notable neologism; later redirected to the CVB-41 class.
10 July 2007 Grand Staircase of the Titanic No consensus
13 July 2007 Schooner Jenny Keep
16 July 2007 List of current ships of the Indonesian Navy Keep
6 August 2007 The Great Lakes Group Keep
17 August 2007 Motor Torpedo Boat PT-337 Keep
5 September 2007 Tiamat (sailing) Nomination withdrawn without any opposes following article improvement
23 October 2007 Encyclopedia Titanica Keep
14 November 2007 USS Watseka (YT-387) Keep
3 December 2007 MSC Armonia Snow Keep
10 December 2007 Brigantine Yankee Keep
17 January 2008 List of Liberty ships by hull number Keep, but later converted into redirect following rework of alphabetical lists using sortable tables.
17 January 2008 List of Liberty ships by hull number, 1 Keep, but later converted into redirect following rework of alphabetical lists using sortable tables.
17 January 2008 List of Liberty ships by hull number, 151 Keep, but later converted into redirect following rework of alphabetical lists using sortable tables.
17 January 2008 List of Liberty ships by hull number, 601 Keep, but later converted into redirect following rework of alphabetical lists using sortable tables.
17 January 2008 List of Liberty ships by hull number, 751 Keep, but later converted into redirect following rework of alphabetical lists using sortable tables.
17 January 2008 List of Liberty ships by hull number, 2101 Keep, but later converted into redirect following rework of alphabetical lists using sortable tables.
19 January 2008 Element Yachts Keep
29 January 2008 USS Illinois (BB-65) / USS Kentucky (BB-66) Keep
29 March 2008 SS Kiche Maru No consensus
24 April 2008 History of Full Rigged Ships Redirect to Full-rigged ship
29 April 2008 Queen of the Netherlands (ship) Snowball Keep
29 April 2008 MY Nemesis Delete
2 May 2008 Titanic alternative theories No consensus
11 May 2008 MV Island Sky Keep
4 July 2008 Princess Kaguya (ship) Delete per WP:CRYSTAL
6 August 2008 MS Prince Albert II Snow Keep
8 September 2008 Four Funnel Liners Keep
5 October 2008 Japanese minelayer Itsukushima Snow Keep
5 October 2008 Japanese minelayer Okinoshima Snow Keep
11 November 2008 Princess Kaguya (cruise ship) Speedy delete under CSD G4
18 November 2008 SS Titan (2012) Speedy delete under CSD G7
19 December 2008 Beramba (ship) Delete as failing WP:V
27 December 2008 SS Timothy Bloodworth Keep
25 October 2008 USS John S. McCain Keep
16 January 2009 SS John Stagg Keep
26 March 2009 FV Monte Galineiro No consensus
26 March 2009 MV Princess of Acadia (1971) Snow Keep
19 May 2009 List of ship launches in 1870 Keep
26 June 2009 National Historic Fleet, Core Collection Nomination withdrawn
26 July 2009 Soho-class frigate Speedy Keep
10 August 2009 Exploding warships Delete as WP:OR
15 December 2009 United States Naval Gunfire Support debate Keep
21 March 2010 Carnival Glory Snow keep
23 March 2010 AIDAsol Keep
21 April 2010 Carnival Dream 3 Delete as WP:CRYSTAL
29 July 2010 HarbourLynx Keep
24 August 2010 MV Mariam Keep
1 September 2010 Golfo Azzurro Delete as failing WP:V; was userified and later restored to mainspace after improvements
20 September 2010 Wherry Maud Keep
28 November 2010 RMS Titan Delete as only a proposed ship, not one currently under construction
9 December 2010 USS Indianapolis in popular culture Delete
13 December 2010 The Sinking of The Adriatic Move to MV Adriatica
14 February 2011 RMS Titanic II (proposed ocean liner) Snow delete, failed WP:N and WP:V.
21 February 2011 Le Pietre (yacht) Delete as failing WP:N due to insufficient coverage by secondary sources.
3 March 2011 USS SC-42 No consensus
14 March 2011 HMS Constance (1880) Snow keep
31 March 2011 USS LST-766 Keep
21 May 2011 MV Portaferry II Keep
1 June 2011 USS Weeks (DE-285) Merge into Rudderow class destroyer escort as never having been constructed.
23 August 2011 MV Ramsey Speedy keep
30 August 2011 MV Peveril (1963) Keep
17 October 2011 Brazos Belle No consensus
5 December 2011 HTMS Pattani Nomination withdrawn on way to snow keep following article improvement.
10 January 2012 MV Spiegelgracht Keep
16 January 2012 TSS Manx Maid (1962) Snow keep
3 March 2012 Atlanship SA Nomination withdrawn, sources found
7 March 2012 Alfa Nero Nomination withdrawn on way to snow keep
14 March 2012 Type C6 ship Snow keep
27 March 2012 Aker American Shipping Nomination withdrawn, sources found
8 April 2012 SS Vesta Redirect to SS Arctic#Sinking
5 May 2012 USS Enterprise (CVN-80) Delete as failing WP:CRYSTAL and WP:V; later recreated when CRYSTAL and V passed.
1 June 2012 List of littoral combat ships of the United States Navy redirect to Littoral combat ship as duplicated info
13 June 2012 Admiralty tug Keep
15 June 2012 Frankfurt (icebreaker) Keep
15 June 2012 Keiler Keep
26 July 2012 USS Illinois (BB-65) / USS Kentucky (BB-66) Keep
1 August 2012 North Sea Boats No consensus
24 August 2012 Replica Titanic Keep with leave to merge
29 August 2012 Delphia Yachts Keep
27 September 2012 European Waterways Keep
27 September 2012 La Belle Epoque (barge) Keep
27 September 2012 L'Art de Vivre Keep
27 September 2012 L'Impressionniste Keep
28 October 2012 Greek destroyer Doxa Snow keep
2 November 2012 Shahrekord super tanker Keep
13 November 2012 SS Buskø Keep
1 December 2012 USS Enterprise (CVN-80) Nomination withdrawn on way to snow keep
8 December 2012 MV Harambee Keep
7 January 2013 H-45 Redirect to H-class battleship proposals
19 January 2013 John B. Caddell Keep
19 February 2013 USS SC-715 Keep
1 June 2013 NoCGV Ålesund Keep
21 June 2013 MV Golden Jubilee Deleted due to lack of sources
16 July 2013 Splash-class cruise ship Deleted per WP:TOOSOON and WP:CRYSTAL
2 August 2013 Western World (British ship) Keep
20 October 2013 MV Seaman Guard Ohio Keep
25 October 2013 Wale Keep
11 November 2013 RV Song of the Whale Keep
20 November 2013 MV Saginaw No consensus
4 December 2013 MV Bni Nsar Keep
15 December 2013 CCGS Ann Harvey Keep
15 December 2013 Chopin (ship) Keep
20 December 2013 S/V Rembrandt van Rijn
S/V Noorderlicht 		Keep both
10 February 2014 Aerial battleship Delete
24 April 2014 Project 21956 Merge to Future of the Russian Navy#Destroyers per WP:CRYSTAL
15 May 2014 Japanese aircraft carrier Project Number G18 Delete as failing WP:V
7 June 2014 LX(R) Delete per WP:CRYSTAL
20 July 2014 USS South Dakota (BB-49) / USS Indiana (BB-50) /

USS Montana (BB-51) / USS North Carolina (BB-52) /
USS Iowa (BB-53) / USS Massachusetts (BB-54)

Redirect all to South Dakota-class battleship (1920) due to virtually identical content on unfinished ships.
4 August 2015 MS Southward Keep
8 August 2015 MV Nimpkish Keep
31 August 2015 Vadne (ferry) Keep
16 November 2015 Boka Star Keep, later moved to Yugoslav auxiliary Ugor.
1 December 2015 List of countries with warships Redirect to list of countries by level of military equipment.
20 February 2016 INS Kolkata Class Destroyer Ship Electrical System Redirect to Kolkata-class destroyer.
7 April 2016 SS Hopestar Nomination withdrawn per WP:NOTCLEANUP.
11 April 2016 USS Letitia (SP-398) Delete as failing WP:V.
16 October 2016 List of Type T2 tankers Keep
29 November 2016 USS Chattanooga (CL-118) Redirect to the class article as a never-completed ship.
6 January 2017 USS Wistaria (SP-259) Delete as never having been commissioned and (thus) failing WP:GNG.
8 March 2017 USS Barracuda (SP-23) Delete as never having been acquired or commissioned and (thus) failing WP:GNG.
14 March 2017 USS Turbot (SS-427) Keep
14 March 2017 USS Ulua (SS-428) Keep
17 April 2017 Long Beach-class cruiser Merge to USS Long Beach (CGN-9) as a single-ship class.
5 June 2017 USS Tahgayuta (1863) Merge to USS Contoocook (1864)#Cootoocook class sloop/frigate as an uncompleted sister ship with no class article yet.
5 June 2017 USS Mondamin (1864) Merge to USS Contoocook (1864)#Cootoocook class sloop/frigate as an uncompleted sister ship with no class article yet.
7 July 2017 High Performance Frigate Program Delete as failing WP:CRYSTAL.
15 July 2017 Future of the Bangladesh Navy Delete as failing WP:CRYSTAL and WP:MADEUP.
28 August 2017 List of frigates of the Republic of China Navy Redirect to List of Republic of China Navy ships#Frigates as an unneeded fork.
30 August 2017 List of Norwegian current frigates Delete as an outdated content fork.
5 November 2017 SS Helsingfors Keep/Withdrawn
1 March 2018 Irlam (1813 ship) Snow keep/nom withdrawn following article improvement.
2 March 2018 SS Corsea Keep - AfD is not for deleting articles in need of improvement.
31 March 2018 John (1803 ship) Delete as non-notable.
1 April 2018 Minerva (1864) Delete as unveifiable
2 April 2018 Jane (ship) Redirect to List of shipwrecks in 1816 as not indvidually notable.
17 May 2018 HMS Forth (1813) Snow keep - AfD is not for deleting articles in need of improvement.
3 October 2018 List of commanding officers of USS Nevada (BB-36) Merge to USS Nevada (BB-36).
6 December 2020 German submarine U-1012 Redirect to the class article as a never-completed ship.
4 January 2021 USS Lillie B (SP-1502) Redirect to List of patrol vessels of the United States Navy as never having been commissioned and (thus) failing WP:GNG.
21 June 2021 SS Ben H. Miller Nomination withdrawn following article expansion.
24 May 2022 German trawler V 206 Otto Bröhan Keep following article improvement.