Composer and critic Alec Wilder mentioned the song in passing in his book American Popular Song: The Great Innovators, 1900–1950, noting that "Sinatra could make every song but 'Jealous Lover' and 'American Beauty Rose' sound reputable."[6]
^William Emmett Studwell, Mark Baldin -The Big Band Reader: Songs Favored by Swing Era Orchestras 2000 0789009145 "However, nothing by Evans, including "American Beauty Rose" (1950, by Hal David, Arthur Altman, and Evans), and ..."
^Frank Sinatra; Evans; David; Altman; Mitch Miller (1950-03-10), American Beauty Rose, Internet Archive, Columbia, retrieved 2023-05-16
^Sinatra! the Song is You: A Singer's Art - Page 180 068419368X Will Friedwald - 1995 "Best of all, Sinatra joyously milks a libretto that funnily and punnily compares girls to flowers. "American Beauty Rose" charted, but hardly high enough to reverse the trend of steadily worsening sales for Sinatra discs that had already started."