In 2007 the band released its self-titled fourth album, which was the first to reach the top five of the Billboard 200 when it peaked at number 4.[3] The All Excess video, released earlier in the year, topped the Billboard Music Video Sales chart and reached number 2 on the UK Music Video Chart.[8][9]Avenged Sevenfold was the band's final full release to feature The Rev, who died of an accidental overdose of prescription drugs and alcohol on December 28, 2009, while they were producing their next album Nightmare.[10]Mike Portnoy performed drums on 2010s Nightmare,[11] which topped the Billboard 200, the first charttopper in the band's career.[3] Lead single "Nightmare" topped the BillboardHeatseekers Songs chart,[12] while third single "So Far Away" became the band's first to top the Mainstream Rock chart.[6] 2011's "Not Ready to Die" topped the UK Rock & Metal Singles Chart.[7]
Arin Ilejay joined as The Rev's second replacement in 2013, performing on the band's sixth studio album Hail to the King.[13] The album followed Nightmare by topping the Billboard 200,[3] as well as being the group's first release to reach number 1 on the Canadian and UK Albums Charts.[14][15] "Hail to the King" and "Shepherd of Fire" both topped the Mainstream Rock chart.[6] In 2014, a re-released Waking the Fallen: Resurrected reached number 10 in the US, 11 years after the original album was released.[2][3] The album would be certified Platinum by the RIAA in 2021.[4]
Brooks Wackerman replaced Ilejay in 2015, and the following year the band released The Stage without any prior announcement.[16] The album reached number 4 on the Billboard 200 and topped the Canadian Albums Chart.[3][14] In 2017, the band began to add to The Stage as part of an "evolving track listing" that would eventually become the album's deluxe version, including cover versions of "God Only Knows" by The Beach Boys, "As Tears Go By" by The Rolling Stones and "Wish You Were Here" by Pink Floyd.[17] Avenged Sevenfold released Live at the Grammy Museum on December 8, 2017, documenting the group's first acoustic performance at the Grammy Museum in October.[18]
After four years of writing and recording,[19] the band released their eighth studio album, Life Is But a Dream... on June 2, 2023,[20] and it peaked at number 13 in the US the same month.[3]