Changed tone

This article is part of the series on the
Cantonese language
Yue Chinese
Grammar
Phonology

Cantonese changed tones (also called pinjam;[1] traditional Chinese: 變音; simplified Chinese: 变音; pinyin: biànyīn; Jyutping: bin3jam1; Cantonese Yale: binyām) occur when a word's tone becomes a different tone due to a particular context or meaning. A "changed" tone is the tone of the word when it is read in a particular lexical or grammatical context, while the base (or underlying) tone is usually the tone of the word when read in citation.[2] It is thus distinct from tone sandhi, which are automatic modifications of tone created by their phonetic environment, without regard to meaning. In its most common form, it occurs on the final syllable of either a compound word, a reduplicated word, or certain vocative examples, especially in direct address to people such as family members.[2] There are a limited set of semantic domains where changed tone occurs, generally associated with small things, familiarity, food and disease.[3]

A changed tone usually takes the form of a non-high level, non-mid rising tone (i.e. tones 3, 4, 5, and 6 in Jyutping and Yale; see Cantonese phonology for further information on the tones in Cantonese) transforming into a mid-rising tone (tone 2); for some speakers, this changed tone is slightly lower than the citation mid-rising tone.[1]

Resulting in mid-rising tone (tone 2)
Chinese characters Jyutping Romanisation English translation
耳環 ji5 waan4-2 earring
男人 naam4 jan4-2 man
港女 gong2 neoi5-2 Kong Girl
眼鏡 ngaan5 geng3-2 glasses
蠄蟧 kam4 lou4-2 spider

In other lexemes, the tone of the last syllable becomes a high level tone (tone 1 in Yale and Jyutping). This is especially true if the penultimate syllable already has tone 1 as its citation tone.[2] For speakers with the high falling tone, this may also become the high level tone via the same process.[1]

Resulting in high level tone (tone 1)
Chinese characters Jyutping Romanisation English translation
今晚 gam1 maan5-1 tonight
蠄蟧絲網 kam4 lou4 si1 mong5-1 spider web, cobweb
包尾 baau1 mei5-1 to come last
自己 zi6 gei2-1 oneself

In many speakers, another form of a changed tone used in specific vocatives that may also result in a high level tone (tone 1), rather than in a mid-level tone.[4]

Almost all non-high level, non-mid rising tone syllables occur changed tone, making unchanged non-high level, non-mid rising tone syllables hardly ever exist.

Due to its extreme unpredictability, Cantonese becomes the most difficult language around the world.

Taishanese also exhibits changed tones. It is realized in some cases as an additional high floating tone to end of the mid level, low level, mid falling and low falling tones; this results in new contours for Taishanese, namely mid rising, low rising, mid dipping and low dipping respectively. The final pitch of these changed tones may be even higher in pitch than the citation high level tone. Another changed tone occurs where the expected tone is replaced by the low falling tone. These two are combined in certain cases, with the result that the expected tone is replaced by the low dipping tone, such as the change of the verb 刷 /tʃat˧/ "to brush" into the noun 刷 /tʃat˨˩˥/ "a brush".[5]

The use of a high rising tone in marking changed tone in many Yue varieties of Chinese implies one possible origin in diminutive morphemes, much in the same way that erhua functions in Standard Mandarin and in the Beijing dialect. In Cantonese, several diminutive morphemes have been proposed as the original one, among them 兒 /jiː˥/ "son" (in its high level tone form) and 子 /t͡siː˧˥/ "child". Thus the changed tone is the relic of the contraction of the main syllable with this diminutive.[1]

A separate tone change that operates on verbs has also been attested, marking the perfective aspect. This is phonetically equivalent to the tone change above in Hong Kong and Guangzhou Cantonese, including the modification for those with a high falling tone.[6]

Base verb Verb after changed tone
Verb Jyutping IPA English meaning Jyutping IPA English meaning
去 heoi3 høi33 go heoi3*2 høi35 went
發 faat3 faːt3 emit faat3*2 faːt35 emitted
賣 maai6 maːi22 sell maai6*2 maːi35 sold
嚟 lai4 lɐi21 come lai4*2 lɐi35 came
買 maai5 maːi13 buy maai5*2 maːi35 bought
落 lok6 lɔk2 fall lok6*2 lɔk35 fell

This is believed to be the result of the merger of the perfective marker 咗 /t͡sɔː˧˥/ into the verb, and is thus also found in other Yue varieties, such as the dialect of Xiaolan in Zhongshan; it is also found in Hakka Chinese varieties, such as some varieties in Heyuan in northern Guangdong, as well as in Shicheng and Yudu in southern Jiangxi.[7] This tone morpheme is even said to predominate over the overt perfective markers in certain areas such as Zhaoqing, Xinhui, Foshan and Shunde, giving rise to a form of tonal ablaut, although this is associated with the speech of the older generation.[7]

  1. ^ a b c d Yu (2007)
  2. ^ a b c Yip & Matthews (2000)
  3. ^ D Jurafsky "On the semantics of Cantonese changed tone or women, matches, and Chinese broccoli", Proceedings of the 14th Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society. Berkeley: Berkeley Linguistics Society. Available online, accessed 24 May 2018
  4. ^ Alan C. L. Yu (publ. pending) "Tonal Mapping in Cantonese Vocative Reduplication", Proceedings of the 35th Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society. Berkeley: Berkeley Linguistics Society. Available online, accessed 4 November 2011
  5. ^ Teresa M. Cheng "The Phonology of Taishan", Journal of Chinese Linguistics, Vol. 1, No. 2 (May 1973), pp. 256-322. [1]
  6. ^ Shan, Yunming 单韵鸣 (21 May 2013). "广州话动词完成体的变异 (Variation in the perfective aspect of the Guangzhou dialect)". 语言科学. 12 (6): 649–757. doi:10.7509/j.linsci.201305.027891. ISSN 1671-9484. Retrieved 25 October 2023.
  7. ^ a b Chappell, Hilary (September 2023). "Tone Morphemes in Sinitic: Where Prosody Meets Morphology". Journal of Chinese Linguistics. doi:10.1353/jcl.2017.a906858. ISSN 2411-3484. Retrieved 25 October 2023.