Nicolay may refer to:
People with surname Nicolay:
- Christian Nicolay (born 1976), German javelin thrower
- Franz Nicolay, American musician and composer
- Jean Nicolay (born 1937), former Belgian football goalkeeper
- John George Nicolay (1832—1901), American biographer and secretary of Abraham Lincoln
- Louis Nicolay, Belgian sports delegate
- Ludwig Heinrich von Nicolay (1737–1820), Russian-German poet, librarian, and president of the St. Petersburg Academy of Sciences
- Mary Ann Nicolay (1850-1939) Matron, UK Nightingale Trainee and Boer War Nurse from Western Australia
- William Nicolay (1771—1842), British soldier