Old Ironsides (trophy)

Tri-State Big Three
Royal blue and gold Pitt script logo
All navy flying WV West Virginia logo
Penn State Nittany Lions Pittsburgh Panthers West Virginia Mountaineers
Trophy: Old Ironsides (1951–84)
First qualifying year: 1900
First full round-robin: 1904
Longest streak: Penn State (1966–75)
Latest champion: Penn State (2023)*
District Championships
Penn State (12)
1901 1905
1906 1908
1909 1919
1939 1941
1942 1943
1947 1950
Pitt (24)
1904 1907
1910 1913
1917 1920
1921 1924
1925 1926
1927 1929
1930 1931
1935 1936
1937 1938
1940 1944
1945 1946
1948 1949
WVU (2)
1922 1928
Outright trophy victories
Penn State (21)
1952 1958
1960 1961
1962 1964
1966 1967
1968 1969
1970 1971
1972 1973
1974 1975
1977 1978
1981 1982
1983 
Pitt (6)
1951 1955
1963 1976
1979 1980
WVU (2)
1953 1984
*No official champions have been crowned since 1984
University locations
Locations of Penn State, Pitt, & WVU

Old Ironsides was the trophy awarded for the three-way college football rivalry between the Penn State Nittany Lions, the Pittsburgh Panthers, and the West Virginia Mountaineers. Although Old Ironsides is the most distinctive aspect of the rivalry, the trophy was long predated by the significance of the universities' collegiate football matches.

In 1984, staff from the Penn State Athletics Department informed their counterparts at Pittsburgh and West Virginia that the trophy went missing at some point while in Penn State's possession. The resulting searches yielded no trace and the Old Ironsides trophy was lost.

As a result of the reduced frequency of competitions between the schools and the disappearance of Old Ironsides, the triangular rivalry is largely viewed in the scope of the individual head-to-head rivalries and not a unified competition between all three.

The three schools were often referred to as the "Tri-State Big Three" or simply the "Big Three".[1] This naming both predated and coexisted with the Old Ironsides trophy. Prior to and concurrent with the attached trophy, the winner of the triangular rivalry was named the "district Big Three champion".[2][3]

  1. ^ Smith, Chester L. (October 27, 1951). "State Renews Old Feud with West Virginia". The Pittsburgh Press. p. 6. Retrieved December 14, 2023.
  2. ^ Hughes, Carl (November 19, 1951). "Teams Rates Even Despite WVU Evidence". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. p. 37. Retrieved December 14, 2023.
  3. ^ Cope, Myron (November 15, 1954). "Pitt in Muddle for State Tilt-Who's on First?". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. p. 26. Retrieved December 22, 2023.