| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Removed material |
4 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Removed material
|
| Country/Chronological or a Topical structure? |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Country/Chronological or a Topical structure?
|
| Coverage of Historical Bans and Motivations |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Coverage of Historical Bans and Motivations
|
| Removed material, replaced with condensed "Trends" overview |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Removed material, replaced with condensed "Trends" overview
|
| References |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#References
|
| Humane methods of kosher slaughter |
4 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Humane methods of kosher slaughter
|
| Encyclopedia??? |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Encyclopedia???
|
| Active bans ? |
3 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Active bans ?
|
| Notes |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Notes
|
| Biased article: too much talk about anti-semitism, too little about animal welfare concerns |
3 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Biased article: too much talk about anti-semitism, too little about animal welfare concerns
|
| Criticism |
3 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Criticism
|
| comment by IP |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#comment by IP
|
| clean up |
3 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#clean up
|
| Australian paper on contemporary ban 1995 on religious slaughter overturned by German Federal Constitutional Court 2002 |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Australian paper on contemporary ban 1995 on religious slaughter overturned by German Federal Constitutional Court 2002
|
| Did big revert |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Did big revert
|
| Criticism |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Criticism 2
|
| copy of letter |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#copy of letter
|
| missing citations? |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#missing citations?
|
| Partisan web sites and Active Ban in United States |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Partisan web sites and Active Ban in United States
|
| Temple Grandin |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Temple Grandin
|
| WP:NPOV, WP:OR, and controversial subjects |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#WP:NPOV, WP:OR, and controversial subjects
|
| Please hold off on big deletions |
3 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Please hold off on big deletions
|
| Request for comments |
11 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Request for comments
|
| Important source |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Important source
|
| edit deleting Jewish and Muslim customs and inserting Jewish and Muslim law |
5 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#edit deleting Jewish and Muslim customs and inserting Jewish and Muslim law
|
| Article does not inform - is more a debating forum than a source of information |
5 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Article does not inform - is more a debating forum than a source of information
|
| change of signature |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#change of signature
|
| the first ban on shehitah was in one Swiss canton, and Reform Jews supported it date: |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#the first ban on shehitah was in one Swiss canton, and Reform Jews supported it date:
|
| Ronit Gurtman's term paper at Harvard - Switzerland 1867 is first date of shehitah ban in one Swiss canton. |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Ronit Gurtman's term paper at Harvard - Switzerland 1867 is first date of shehitah ban in one Swiss canton.
|
| reference used by Ronit Gurtman (I think) |
8 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#reference used by Ronit Gurtman (I think)
|
| Another view |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Another view
|
| stupid stupid stupid |
6 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#stupid stupid stupid
|
| Iowa Plant material |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Iowa Plant material
|
| Refs lost during deletions |
4 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 1#Refs lost during deletions
|
| To clear up some misunderstandings |
3 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#To clear up some misunderstandings
|
| Lower |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#Lower
|
| outdated information re: Austria. |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#outdated information re: Austria.
|
| Unfair and dishonest |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#Unfair and dishonest
|
| New Article Name |
5 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#New Article Name
|
| Active issues |
9 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#Active issues
|
| correction |
5 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#correction
|
| Newspaper article 29 Novermber 2005 mentions EU directive |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#Newspaper article 29 Novermber 2005 mentions EU directive
|
| EU directive |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#EU directive
|
| Statement from Swedish Jews, Muslims and Social Democratic Christians addressed to the Swedish Department of Agriculture |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#Statement from Swedish Jews, Muslims and Social Democratic Christians addressed to the Swedish Department of Agriculture
|
| Sikh ritual slaugher/religious slaughter |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#Sikh ritual slaugher/religious slaughter
|
| This is the old EEC directive that is no longer in force. Article 4 is the relevant item. |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#This is the old EEC directive that is no longer in force. Article 4 is the relevant item.
|
| deletions |
4 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#deletions
|
| dates wrong, two legal systems clash, but neither is prohibited or restricted. |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#dates wrong, two legal systems clash, but neither is prohibited or restricted.
|
| EU activities in the religious slaughter area |
7 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#EU activities in the religious slaughter area
|
| earliest date of bans in the eight hundreds |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#earliest date of bans in the eight hundreds
|
| Response to long, unsourced rant accusation |
3 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#Response to long, unsourced rant accusation
|
| Historic bans title is not historic - it refers to bans in force now |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#Historic bans title is not historic - it refers to bans in force now
|
| Correct chronology of bans on Jewish slaughter |
3 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#Correct chronology of bans on Jewish slaughter
|
| Sikh slaughter (Jhakta) |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#Sikh slaughter (Jhakta)
|
| Legal bans affect Jews imposing disabilities on Jews who cannot eat the same kind of food as others. |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#Legal bans affect Jews imposing disabilities on Jews who cannot eat the same kind of food as others.
|
| Article in the Economist this week |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#Article in the Economist this week
|
| shehitah in wikipedia - other languages |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#shehitah in wikipedia - other languages
|
| Pascal Krauthammer. Das schächtverbot in der Schweiz. First two paragraphs of abstract. |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#Pascal Krauthammer. Das schächtverbot in der Schweiz. First two paragraphs of abstract.
|
| Moving section with opinions criticizing ritual slaughter to talk page |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#Moving section with opinions criticizing ritual slaughter to talk page
|
| Removed six Austrian provinces for the second time from the list of shehitah bans |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#Removed six Austrian provinces for the second time from the list of shehitah bans
|
| "The Swiss banned kosher slaughter in 1902." no, they did not |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#"The Swiss banned kosher slaughter in 1902." no, they did not
|
| very silly to divide the subject up into countries and tell their stories individually |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#very silly to divide the subject up into countries and tell their stories individually
|
| Sweden and Norway |
11 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#Sweden and Norway
|
| Switzerland |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 2#Switzerland
|
| Spain, NL and Finland |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#Spain, NL and Finland
|
| Proposed bans |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#Proposed bans
|
| New Zealand |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#New Zealand
|
| European history and Shechita: controversies and legislation |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#European history and Shechita: controversies and legislation
|
| moved from article "Halal" |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#moved from article "Halal"
|
| Animal welfare controversies |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#Animal welfare controversies
|
| Moved from "Dhabhiha" article |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#Moved from "Dhabhiha" article
|
| Public Debates in the 1880s |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#Public Debates in the 1880s
|
| reference |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#reference
|
| Switzerland |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#Switzerland
|
| References 37 and 38 in the article at this date give Johansen - Who is Johansen? |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#References 37 and 38 in the article at this date give Johansen - Who is Johansen?
|
| OR and European Convention on Human Rights |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#OR and European Convention on Human Rights
|
| The section describing ritual slaughter in Poland |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#The section describing ritual slaughter in Poland
|
| Proposal to Remove "dispute" template from heading of article |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#Proposal to Remove "dispute" template from heading of article
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#External links modified
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#External links modified 2
|
| May 23, 2011 Expert Opinion on Considerations When Evaluating All Types of Slaughter: Mechanical, Electrical, Gas and Religious Slaughter And A Critical Scientific Review of Report 161: Ritual Slaughter and Animal Welfare (September, 2008); Report 398: Re |
2 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#May 23, 2011 Expert Opinion on Considerations When Evaluating All Types of Slaughter: Mechanical, Electrical, Gas and Religious Slaughter And A Critical Scientific Review of Report 161: Ritual Slaughter and Animal Welfare (September, 2008); Report 398: Re
|
| Section on Belgium to be added |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#Section on Belgium to be added
|
| Legality of European regulation |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter/Archive 3#Legality of European regulation
|
| Does the animal die from loss of blood? and where is this sourced from? |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter#Does the animal die from loss of blood? and where is this sourced from?
|
| European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter#European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter#External links modified
|
| Reference |
1 |
Talk:Legal aspects of ritual slaughter#Reference
|