| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Much needed ... |
5 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Much needed ...
|
| Suggested outline structure for this article |
7 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Suggested outline structure for this article
|
| Lead in |
5 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Lead in
|
| Oh dear, oh dear ... |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Oh dear, oh dear ...
|
| Title of article |
2 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Title of article
|
| Merge? |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Merge?
|
| "Commentators" section |
2 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#"Commentators" section
|
| Synthesis |
8 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Synthesis
|
| Not a Neologism! |
5 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Not a Neologism!
|
| Secondary level sources |
3 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Secondary level sources
|
| Feuerbach? |
3 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Feuerbach?
|
| What's best for the article |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#What's best for the article
|
| New and imporoved article |
10 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#New and imporoved article
|
| Other definitions |
5 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Other definitions
|
| Why do we need a separate section on Marxism-Leninism? |
2 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Why do we need a separate section on Marxism-Leninism?
|
| Neologism???/Not appropriate |
5 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Neologism???/Not appropriate
|
| Baggini |
5 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Baggini
|
| Bad examples. |
5 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Bad examples.
|
| Pejorative? |
9 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Pejorative?
|
| Removal of sourced information |
4 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Removal of sourced information
|
| Stuffing the article with “well-referenced” facts in order to push a point of view |
18 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Stuffing the article with “well-referenced” facts in order to push a point of view
|
| Uneven and blatant hypocritical behavior |
15 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Uneven and blatant hypocritical behavior
|
| What is Militant Atheism? |
21 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#What is Militant Atheism?
|
| Militant atheism as a side-effect of materialism should provide the basis for edits. |
22 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Militant atheism as a side-effect of materialism should provide the basis for edits.
|
| A way forward? |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#A way forward?
|
| Uh, may I interrupt with a question not related to this dispute? |
3 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Uh, may I interrupt with a question not related to this dispute?
|
| Suggested solution |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Suggested solution
|
| EASY |
8 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#EASY
|
| Second suggestion: article structure |
7 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 1#Second suggestion: article structure
|
| Just a short comment |
31 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 2#Just a short comment
|
| Proposed structure |
55 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 2#Proposed structure
|
| The word "sometimes" in the lead sentence |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 2#The word "sometimes" in the lead sentence
|
| Christopher Hitchens' comment about the Russian Orthodox Church |
25 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 2#Christopher Hitchens' comment about the Russian Orthodox Church
|
| Torture committed in order to treat the "mental illness" of theism by atheistic regimes |
56 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 2#Torture committed in order to treat the "mental illness" of theism by atheistic regimes
|
| China and the militant atheist |
10 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 2#China and the militant atheist
|
| The 'Cambridge Encyclopedia' on stateuniversity.com |
1 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 2#The 'Cambridge Encyclopedia' on stateuniversity.com
|
| (random heading) |
7 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#(random heading)
|
| Concerns about the use of the term |
7 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#Concerns about the use of the term
|
| Coat rack |
2 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#Coat rack
|
| Soviet Bloc |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#Soviet Bloc
|
| VERY ONE SIDED |
1 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#VERY ONE SIDED
|
| Use of article as coatrack |
9 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#Use of article as coatrack
|
| Section appears to have no relevance to militant atheism. |
15 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#Section appears to have no relevance to militant atheism.
|
| Opening sentence failed verification |
5 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#Opening sentence failed verification
|
| Split article? |
60 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#Split article?
|
| Quoted material not in quote marks |
8 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#Quoted material not in quote marks
|
| Dumping quotes from sources that happen to use a term does not make an encyclopedia article. |
14 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#Dumping quotes from sources that happen to use a term does not make an encyclopedia article.
|
| Lede - TWO claims sufficient for State atheism? |
2 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#Lede - TWO claims sufficient for State atheism?
|
| "Ideology of hostility"? |
3 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#"Ideology of hostility"?
|
| "Atheist fundamentalism"? |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#"Atheist fundamentalism"?
|
| French Revolution |
1 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#French Revolution
|
| Sequence in lede |
10 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#Sequence in lede
|
| This article should be merged with antitheism/antireligion |
11 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#This article should be merged with antitheism/antireligion
|
| Improvement |
34 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#Improvement
|
| Added a neutrality dispute tag |
1 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 3#Added a neutrality dispute tag
|
| Reponse to Mann Jess |
9 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#Reponse to Mann Jess
|
| 1) "Militant atheist" as a pejorative slur and 2) the massive bias in groups following this article |
12 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#1) "Militant atheist" as a pejorative slur and 2) the massive bias in groups following this article
|
| Kathy Griffin |
4 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#Kathy Griffin
|
| citation 16 |
3 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#citation 16
|
| Why were my references removed? |
26 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#Why were my references removed?
|
| Who and what deserves the label "militant atheist"? Who gets to decide? |
15 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#Who and what deserves the label "militant atheist"? Who gets to decide?
|
| Actually using the word "militant"... |
7 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#Actually using the word "militant"...
|
| Further proposals |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#Further proposals
|
| Let's accurately flesh out the disambiguation proposal |
2 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#Let's accurately flesh out the disambiguation proposal
|
| Sources for those who deny that there's any controversy |
9 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#Sources for those who deny that there's any controversy
|
| Anupam's revert of the CNN reference |
51 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#Anupam's revert of the CNN reference
|
| Placed a reference version of the current lead on a talk-draft page. |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#Placed a reference version of the current lead on a talk-draft page.
|
| Removing the NPOV dispute tag??? Are you FREAKING KIDDING ME?????????? |
5 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#Removing the NPOV dispute tag??? Are you FREAKING KIDDING ME??????????
|
| User:Mann jess' removal of references |
24 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 5#User:Mann jess' removal of references
|
| Continued reversion without discussion |
8 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 5#Continued reversion without discussion
|
| Move to replace introduction of article |
10 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#Move to replace introduction of article
|
| Reliable sources relating militant atheism with the New Atheism movement? |
5 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#Reliable sources relating militant atheism with the New Atheism movement?
|
| I suggest we request formal mediation |
4 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 4#I suggest we request formal mediation
|
| Epistle of hope |
7 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 5#Epistle of hope
|
| Synthesis |
26 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 5#Synthesis
|
| Word Razor |
3 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 5#Word Razor
|
| LEDE written by PeaceLoveHarmony |
33 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 5#LEDE written by PeaceLoveHarmony
|
| Second paragraph issues |
1 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 5#Second paragraph issues
|
| Deletions? |
1 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 5#Deletions?
|
| Research on early usesUsed 2002 |
11 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 5#Research on early usesUsed 2002
|
| Bad wording - this article is grossly POV |
5 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 5#Bad wording - this article is grossly POV
|
| "Philosphically speaking" Bad grammar |
2 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 5#"Philosphically speaking" Bad grammar
|
| The problem with this "small" revert is... |
1 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 5#The problem with this "small" revert is...
|
| Edit #441259171 |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 5#Edit #441259171
|
| Proposal for consensus-in-principal on structural revision |
3 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 5#Proposal for consensus-in-principal on structural revision
|
| Addition? |
1 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 5#Addition?
|
| Is "MA" a Hoax to begin with? Inherent structural/molecular flaw in this article, throughout. |
1 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Is "MA" a Hoax to begin with? Inherent structural/molecular flaw in this article, throughout.
|
| Edit conflic:t Anapum/Jess; Third opinion oon "toxic to humans" |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Edit conflic:t Anapum/Jess; Third opinion oon "toxic to humans"
|
| Introduction |
15 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Introduction
|
| Lede has prominent POV distortion . Notice of Intent to Edit. |
5 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Lede has prominent POV distortion . Notice of Intent to Edit.
|
| Another POV distortion error: Baggini was an atheist |
2 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Another POV distortion error: Baggini was an atheist
|
| Word razor on hold |
1 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Word razor on hold
|
| Long strecth from 1890's to 2009 please clarify |
7 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Long strecth from 1890's to 2009 please clarify
|
| 'militant atheism' and doctrine |
4 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#'militant atheism' and doctrine
|
| Please respect the EDIT NOTICE: No major shift w/o consensus |
22 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Please respect the EDIT NOTICE: No major shift w/o consensus
|
| Why keep readers in the dark? |
3 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Why keep readers in the dark?
|
| Off topic link, what is the point of this link? |
4 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Off topic link, what is the point of this link?
|
| Untranslated foreign language citations ??? |
2 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Untranslated foreign language citations ???
|
| Proposed re-ordering: French Revolution prior to Russian/Bolshevik period. |
2 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Proposed re-ordering: French Revolution prior to Russian/Bolshevik period.
|
| Anupam's disruptive editing |
10 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Anupam's disruptive editing
|
| RE: Today: Please disentangle Michael Ruse,[118][119] and Bruce Sheiman [120], |
2 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#RE: Today: Please disentangle Michael Ruse,[118][119] and Bruce Sheiman [120],
|
| Froes (ref 66) POV presented as fact and way overstated |
2 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Froes (ref 66) POV presented as fact and way overstated
|
| TWO main uses |
4 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#TWO main uses
|
| Intermingling of dubious POV assessments |
1 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Intermingling of dubious POV assessments
|
| Closure of Introduction Issue and Word Razor Solution |
20 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Closure of Introduction Issue and Word Razor Solution
|
| Cite formatting: google books and quote parameter |
13 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 6#Cite formatting: google books and quote parameter
|
| Dispute discussion |
13 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 7#Dispute discussion
|
| POV in "Militant atheism regards itself as a doctrine to be propagated" |
11 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 7#POV in "Militant atheism regards itself as a doctrine to be propagated"
|
| Lead paragraph - unresolved |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 7#Lead paragraph - unresolved
|
| Militant atheism article finds his home |
42 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 9#Militant atheism article finds his home
|
| Binksternet's revision |
18 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 7#Binksternet's revision
|
| What happened to dialectical materialism? |
5 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 7#What happened to dialectical materialism?
|
| This article seems to be written to advance a particular viewpoint |
51 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 7#This article seems to be written to advance a particular viewpoint
|
| Militant atheists have a desire to propagate the doctrine |
11 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 8#Militant atheists have a desire to propagate the doctrine
|
| Secondary Sources |
2 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 8#Secondary Sources
|
| "The Freedom From Religion Foundation, however, has been called a "militant atheist group" in The Washington Examiner” |
19 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 8#"The Freedom From Religion Foundation, however, has been called a "militant atheist group" in The Washington Examiner”
|
| Semi-protection |
1 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 8#Semi-protection
|
| Cherry-picking |
12 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 8#Cherry-picking
|
| Full protection |
8 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 8#Full protection
|
| Should the article be split? |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 8#Should the article be split?
|
| Should the article be split or made into a disambiguation page? |
180 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 8#Should the article be split or made into a disambiguation page?
|
| Minor edit suggestion |
2 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 8#Minor edit suggestion
|
| Stop edit warring over WikiProjects |
23 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 8#Stop edit warring over WikiProjects
|
| Be still my beating heart!! A source!! |
36 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 8#Be still my beating heart!! A source!!
|
| Please alter statement about Michael Ruse |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 8#Please alter statement about Michael Ruse
|
| RFC closed, building the db |
34 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 9#RFC closed, building the db
|
| Incoming redirects |
15 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 9#Incoming redirects
|
| Including New Atheism |
20 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 9#Including New Atheism
|
| Move to Atheism (disambiguation) |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 9#Move to Atheism (disambiguation)
|
| Requested Redirect |
12 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 9#Requested Redirect
|
| Redirect to New Atheism |
1 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 9#Redirect to New Atheism
|
| Transform the redirection in a disambiguation page |
24 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 9#Transform the redirection in a disambiguation page
|
| Attempts to overturn consensus |
5 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 10#Attempts to overturn consensus
|
| Actual article content |
6 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 10#Actual article content
|
| Wrong redirect |
1 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 10#Wrong redirect
|
| Protected edit request on 9 March 2017 |
12 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 10#Protected edit request on 9 March 2017
|
| Proposal to change the primary target to "New atheism" |
4 |
Talk:Militant atheism/Archive 10#Proposal to change the primary target to "New atheism"
|
| Protected edit request on 15 December 2022 |
2 |
Talk:Militant atheism#Protected edit request on 15 December 2022
|
| Short description needed |
4 |
Talk:Militant atheism#Short description needed
|