The result was no consensus. There's two basic arguments in play here.
The first is whether some of the sources, specifically Destructoid and Rock, Paper, Shotgun are WP:RS. I don't know the full history of WP:VG/S, i.e. is it just an essay, or real policy, but those two sources are listed there and it seems like a cogent analysis of the source space, so I'm going to accept that they're both WP:RS.
The second is whether the actual cited references are really indicative of WP:N, or if they're just recycled press releases. I can't discern any consensus on that point.
I don't know if this should be closed as keep or no consensus. Given that they're effectively the same thing, however, I'm not to going sweat it. -- RoySmith (talk) 17:42, 13 April 2018 (UTC)