Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Game Factory Interactive

The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this page.

The result was as follows:

• Keep Paradise Cracked and Alfa: Antiterror although there may be a renomination later. During the discussion the nomination withdrew his support for deletion of the two games, and that leaves two delete votes, one citing that the games are "lacking in depth coverage" without further analysis and a "per nom", later the nom as we saw, has withdrawn the nomination statement. My role here is to determine whether there is a consensus for deletion (there is not) or if there is any policy violation in the article that mandates deletion (given that some possible sources have been proposed in this discussion, the problems may be surmountable). As such, I find that any consensus that might be here is closer to keeping than it is to deleting.
• No consensus on GFI Russia and Game Factory Interactive. Both Odie5533 and Hellknowz have both advocated merging these together, although Alex Spade has objected to that. I am at this point unable to assess the pros and cons of merging them, so I leave that up to regular editorial practices. If someone thinks they can be merged neatly, they may be bold and do so.

The debate is slightly confusing because there is a bundle of nominations here, and in hindsight the bundling may not have been the best idea. (But this is very much in hindsight, where we have the added benefit of seeing how the debate actually developed.)

I note that the sourcing currently cited in the articles is still imperfect in some of the areas that provoked this AFD, for example many of the sources are not independent of the subject and others are iffy on reliability. Sjakkalle (Check!) 11:05, 16 December 2012 (UTC)[reply]