The result was redirect to List of Pakistan women ODI cricketers. It would be defensible to close this as No Consensus. There is fundamental disagreement here about the relative importance of the WP:SNGs vs WP:GNG, and I don't see how any amount of relists will resolve that. The issue of WP:CANVASSING is of some concern as well. Ultimately, I found Blue Square Thing's arguments why a redirect makes sense, to be convincing. As noted, should better sourcing emerge in the future, the redirect can be undone by any editor. -- RoySmith (talk) 16:32, 27 August 2019 (UTC)