The result was Keep, but Rename. The consensus here appears to be narrowly in favor of Keeping the article. The primary criticism of the article was WP:BLP1E, which notes that individuals should not have articles if their notability is related to one event (or, as here, to one set of events closely related enough to be considered one for these purposes). Even then, several who recommended Delete noted that a merge would work as well, or that the information should be kept somewhere. Several on the Keep side of the debate also noted the concern, and recommended a rename of the article. So the result is that we have both sides of the debate seeking to keep some of the information by moving it to a new title.
As noted below, the debate on where to move this article should take place on its talk page. The most frequently cited target for such a move was Shona Holmes incident, which seems to be the most neutral of the possible move targets - but that discussion is beyond the scope of this debate.
One final note - the article does need some significant cleaning up, and I'm surprised more people didn't note that here. Again, not material to this closing, but I thought it wise to mention. UltraExactZZ Claims ~ Evidence 13:17, 1 October 2009 (UTC)[reply]