The result of the debate was: This one is one of the most complex MFDs that I've seen or closed in my almost three years in this project. I did a full evauation of each of the comments made in both here and the AN/I comment. I just couldn't read consensus for most of this debate. Alot of moot votes in both sides of the debate, many WP:ILIKEIT, and the comments to comparing this to myspace and calling it "useless rubbish" is plain WP:IDONTLIKEIT so they cancel each other out. WP:NOT#MYSPACE was created for editors not to abuse the website by chatting and avoiding any types of mainspace contributions. Here with some of the secret pages, it doesn't seem to be the case. Those secret pages aren't chat rooms, just promoting a little fun with a barnstar. In my opinion it's plain silly, but policies trump personal opinions, and there is no clear policy that prohibits this thing. Many of the users here are long standing users with many namespace edits looking to build community interaction. Other comments that were valid included a selective delete of the worst of the violations, but that is what mass MFDs of many pages aren't for. I'm deleting the fake secret pages, as consenus was formed here, and the rest of those pages should be on a case on case basis. Note this is not a keep result. Secret account 21:24, 5 April 2008 (UTC)[reply]