| Pixelface
|
30 Dec 2008
|
Pixelface, in participating in discussions regarding Wikipedia policy on fiction topics, engages in an editing style and discussion style that is uncivil and disruptive to the encyclopedia, which does not help in establishing a consensus for how these topics should be dealt with.
|
Masem, Protonk.
|
Responses and outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
|
| Law Lord
|
21 Dec 2008
|
Self-filed RFC with questions on personal attacks and abuse of admin tools.
|
Self-filed by Law Lord.
|
Proposal to close enacted - by agreement of involved users (as well as uninvolved users). RFC closed as resolved.
|
| Gavin.collins 2
|
5 Dec 2008
|
Accusations of conflict of interest, disparaging remarks, and hostile tone.
|
Drilnoth, BOZ
|
Agreement to a 3-month break from editing articles around other involved editors.
|
| Pé de Chinelo
|
29 Nov 2008
|
Removing references and edit warring on video game articles
|
MuZemike, chocobogamer, GamerPro64
|
User blocked indefinitely at WP:AN.
|
| EmilEikS
|
25 Nov 2008
|
Issues with User:EmilEikS regarding overall overt and implied behavior which is contentious and disruptive to the project.
|
Wildhartlivie, Momoricks
|
EmilEikS retired from Wikipedia on 1 December 2008.
|
| Thunderbird2
|
21 Nov 2008
|
Repeated disruptive POINTY editing.
|
Fnagaton, Greg L
|
Delisted due to inactivity; no response; one outside view.
|
| jmh649
|
15 Nov 2008
|
The main problem is Doc James' article ownership and the personal attacks and editwarring that accompany it.
|
Vannin, Vaoverland
|
Delisted due to inactivity; parties to discuss content on article talk page.
|
| Slrubenstein
|
10 Nov 2008
|
Made an unblock without any attempt to contact the blocking admin or to have the block reviewed first.
|
Charles Matthews, Jehochman
|
RFC-initiators agreed to close the RFC as resolved.
|
| Privatemusings
|
6 Nov 2008
|
Disruption of the community by failing to accept consensus.
|
MBisanz, Lar
|
Mixed responses and outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
|
| Roux
|
30 Oct 2008
|
Incivil and abusive behaviour, on both talk pages and in edit summaries, tendenitious editing, refusal to cooperate in discussion.
|
G2bambino, Mayalld
|
Editing restrictions imposed per this RFC, and G2bambino blocked.
|
| Blackworm
|
25 Oct 2008
|
Ongoing problems related to Blackworm's behaviour at the Circumcision article and related articles.
|
Coppertwig, Jakew
|
Delisted due to inactivity; no outside views.
|
| Hemanshu
|
21 Oct 2008
|
That Hemanshu has failed to respond to inquiries about his edits.
|
MBisanz, Jaysweet
|
User stopped editing on 7 November 2008.
|
| G2bambino
|
16 Oct 2008
|
Incivility, POV pushing, refusal to co-operate in discussions
|
Roux, Mayalld
|
Editing restrictions imposed.
|
| Matt reltub
|
7 Oct 2008
|
Has assumed aggressive and attacking behavior, has made unwarranted accusations of Meat Puppetry, and has attempted to take control of the article without coming to a dispute resolution.
|
Rabicante, Mayalld
|
All three editors stopped editing Wikipedia. Parties certifying dispute were blocked for sockpuppetry before departure.
|
| GabrielVelasquez
|
6 Oct 2008
|
Has engaged in out-of-the-blue personal attacks, failed to assume good faith, tossed around several accusations of sockpuppetry and in general he is prone to aggressive, disruptive behaviour.
|
Cyclopia, Icalanise
|
Delisted due to inactivity. Clear consensus that although GabrielVelasquez makes good faith attempts to improve the project, he needs to spend more time thinking about how his words and tone may be taken by others - to avoid repeatedly coming into conflict with others.
|
| Marvin Shilmer
|
29 Sep 2008
|
Bias against Jehovah's Witnesses, incivility and condescension, claims of 'character assassination', ignoring Wikipedia guidelines regarding archived articles in User subpages
|
Jeffro77
|
RFC withdrawn, resolved at Talk.
|
| Expeditionradio
|
28 Sep 2008
|
Disruptive and single-subject editing of articles on Automatic link establishment, violations of WP:COI, WP:SPA, WP:OWN, WP:LUC, WP:CIVIL, WP:VANDAL
|
Manway, Tallaeus
|
Editor stopped editing on October 2 2008.
|
| Alleichem
|
25 Sep 2008
|
Disruptive and single-subject editing of articles on God's name, violations of WP:NPOV, WP:V, WP:NOR, WP:UNDUE, WP:CIVIL
|
LisaLiel
|
User banned as repeat sockpuppet.
|
| Davidruben
|
23 Sep 2008
|
Davidruben promoted WP:MEDRS to guideline over well-argued objections of several editors. He then took sides in the resulting dispute by reverting to the version of the page he prefers and protecting the revert.
|
Paul gene, Colonel Warden
|
Mixed responses and outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
|
| Davegnz
|
18 Sep 2008
|
User showing long-standing pattern of behaviours inconsistent with a communal, collegiate environment, including incivility, threatened and actual disruption, unwillingness to abide by consensus, and sense of ownership of material.
|
Rlandmann, Askari Mark
|
Editor stopped editing on 24 October 2008 - should he return and continue engaging in the problematic conduct brought up in this RFC, he may be sanctioned accordingly.
|
| Kainaw
|
17 Sep 2008
|
Incivility, assumption of bad faith.
|
Philcha, Sjakkalle
|
Response and outside view; delisted due to inactivity.
|
| Roberttheman2008
|
11 Sep 2008
|
User showing blatant disregard for Wikipedia policies and guidelines via making threats and incivility during an AfD.
|
MuZemike, JuJube
|
Further disruption will lead to an indef block; Roberttheman2008 stopped editing September 21 2008.
|
| Tony1
|
8 Sep 2008
|
Unlinking dates without appropriate discussion, in defiance of requests to temporarily hold off.
|
UC_Bill, Sapphic
|
Tony1's edits accepted as correct.
|
| Goingoveredge
|
31 Aug 2008
|
Reverting and deleting information without appropriate discussion.
|
Princhest, Roadahead
|
Parties warned not to edit war, Goingoveredge warned not to make personal attacks.
|
| Future Perfect at Sunrise
|
30 Aug 2008
|
Issues with behavior and policy interpretations, primarily centered around images
|
Sumoeagle179, John
|
Future Perfect at Sunrise warned to follow WP:CIVIL and WP:NPA.
|
| Particleman24
|
30 Aug 2008
|
No understanding of policy such as WP:V and WP:NPOV.
|
Yngvarr, Treelo
|
Particleman24 stopped editing on 27 August 2008.
|
| Sceptre 2
|
28 Aug 2008
|
Self-filed RFC.
|
Sceptre, MBisanz
|
Sceptre retired on 29 August 2008.
|
| Majorly
|
27 Aug 2008
|
Self-filed RFC.
|
Balloonman, MBisanz
|
Majorly requested desysopping on 2 September 2008, and was desysopped by a steward at meta.
|
| Sarumio
|
18 Aug 2008
|
Ignores consensus in making mass edits to articles related to football clubs
|
Dweller, The Rambling Man
|
Delisted due to inactivity.
|
| Fasach Nua 2
|
15 Aug 2008
|
Disruptive edits and edit warring in the 'Notable Player' sections of 'National Football Team' articles.
|
Aaron_carass, SoWhy
|
Mixed outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
|
| InternetHero
|
14 Aug 2008
|
Personal attacks, edit-warring, vandalism and undue weight/sourcing problems. But user appears to in good faith believe his edits are neutral.
|
DigitalC, Mark Chovain
|
InternetHero has made no edits for three weeks, and appears to be retired.
|
| JJL
|
12 Aug 2008
|
An editor who has a tendency to be disruptive, uncivil, and unwilling to compromise.
|
Omnedon, Huwmanbeing
|
Delisted due to inactivity.
|
| Elonka
|
1 Aug 2008
|
Concerns about the management of editing conditions.
|
ChrisO, Ned Scott
|
See Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Elonka#Conclusion
|
| MAL01159
|
29 Jul 2008
|
A disruptive and tendentious single purpose account. MAL01159 has disputed every source provided by other editors, but has not provided any source to back up their own position.
|
SheffieldSteel, Kingturtle
|
MAL01159 is warned about making edits contrary to consensus, and urged to read the policies on original research, consensus, WP:V, and WP:NPOV. Further disruption will result in a block.
|
| Psychobillypolice
|
25 Jul 2008
|
New user who has revert-warred, made uncivil comments and mild threats, and responds to constructive criticisms with hostility.
|
IllaZilla, JD554
|
Psychobillypolice stopped editing on 25 July 2008.
|
| Posturewriter
|
20 Jul 2008
|
Long-term tendentious and disruptive editing, personal attacks and bad-faith statements.
|
Gordonofcartoon, EdJohnston
|
Posturewriter is reminded of the WP:COI policy, and asked to avoid editing articles that fall under that scope for him. Further COI issues may result in a topic ban.
|
| Bogdangiusca
|
19 Jul 2008
|
Moved unilaterally a page whose name has been very controversial, against the Wikipedia policy.
|
AKoan, Kuaichik
|
Case deferred to mediation
|
| Exidor
|
17 Jul 2008
|
Refusal to follow consensus, personal attacks, incivility.
|
Tedickey, Karnesky
|
Exidor warned to be more civil.
|
| Florentino floro
|
17 Jul 2008
|
For repeated violation of notability, relevance, and npov guidelines.
|
TheCoffee, Cma
|
Florentino floro warned in regards to trivial additions, behavioral tendencies, and long messages.
|
| Kirill Lokshin
|
16 Jul 2008
|
Self-filed RFC/U, primarily regarding arbitration-related conduct.
|
Kirill Lokshin, John Carter
|
Kirill's actions are considered satisfactory - it is hoped that lessons are learned for the future.
|
| Cleo123
|
10 Jul 2008
|
Disruptive, incivil commentary on others, possibly willful misapplication of policies and guidelines, little apparent interest in seeking consensus.
|
Tendancer, Ottava Rima
|
Cleo123 warned about BLP reversions, encouraged to use WP:BLP/N. Cleo123 hasn't edited since July 10.
|
| Alastair Haines
|
7 Jul 2008
|
Refusal to follow consensus, personal attacks, incivility.
|
Rushyo, L'Aquatique
|
Alastair Haines warned to be civil and not to make legal threats; case sent to arbitration.
|
| Rvaste
|
6 Jul 2008
|
In Leonard Feeney, persistent posting of same version, no response to attempts at communication.
|
Jnestorius, Garion96
|
Rvaste indefinitely blocked.
|
| GoRight
|
4 Jul 2008
|
Disruptive editing, BLP editing, Harassment.
|
William M. Connolley, Raul654
|
All involved users in the dispute advised to engage in appropriate conduct. GoRight subject to a community sanction.
|
| Marburg72
|
3 Jul 2008
|
Problems with WP:3RR, WP:COIN, WP:OR and general refusal to accept information which conflicts with his own ideas.
|
David Trochos, Dougweller
|
Marburg72 blocked for 24 hours. Indefinitely blocked on 1 July 2011 for abusing multiple accounts.
|
| Dorftrottel
|
23 Jun 2008
|
Self-filed Rfc/U, following considerable criticism about civility.
|
Dorftrottel, Casliber
|
Dorftrottel cautioned regarding civility, warned about future sanctions
|
| CarolSpears
|
22 Jun 2008
|
WP:COPYVIO
|
Shoemaker's Holiday, Durova
|
CarolSpears indefinitely blocked after subsequent ANI report.
|
| Esimal
|
18 Jun 2008
|
Personal attacks, edit warring, POV pushing.
|
The Evil Spartan, Cuchullain
|
Esimal retired from Wikipedia on 18 June 2008.
|
| Greg_L
|
4 Jun 2008
|
Constant incivility, disregard for consensus, votemongering, vote stacking.
|
Omegatron, Thunderbird2
|
Both parties given substantial feedback on their conduct - delisted due to relative inactivity.
|
| Tom_davy
|
23 May 2008
|
User edits without communication, only reverting and undo edits of others.
|
Dchall1, Boogalouie
|
Tom davy stopped editing on 25 June 2008, proposed remedy adopted should he return.
|
| Zeuspitar
|
23 May 2008
|
Incivility, disruptive editing, personal attacks, legal threats, using Wikipedia as a battlefield.
|
Wikidas, Shruti14
|
Zeuspitar stopped editing on 3 July 2008.
|
| TheNautilus/I'clast
|
21 May 2008
|
Abuse of multiple accounts. Refusal to abide by content policies and respect consensus, edit warring.
|
TimVickers, Fyslee
|
TheNautilus stopped editing on 3 June 2008; I'clast stopped editing on 23 May 2008.
|
| Lilith2396
|
21 May 2008
|
Constant insults and attacks on other users. Sockpuppetry.
|
TallNapoleon, Idag
|
Per Wikipedia:Suspected sock puppets/Spinoza1111, Lilith2396 was blocked for 2 months by EdJohnston. He has stopped editing since.
|
| Abtract
|
20 May 2008
|
Edit warring, incivility, gaming the system, personal attacks.
|
Collectonian, Arcayne
|
Abtract was blocked a couple of times, and then stopped editing on 23 June 2008.
|
| LahoreKid
|
14 May 2008
|
WP:CIVIL, WP:BLP
|
NEDian, WWGB
|
Delisted due to inactivity; LahoreKid hasn't edited since June 1
|
| 69.121.221.174
|
6 May 2008
|
Incivility/Edit-warring
|
Idag, Ethan a adawe
|
Anon stopped editing on 18 June 2008.
|
| VoABot II
|
5 May 2008
|
Blind bot reverting of new users
|
Hesperian, Soxred93
|
Issue resolved.
|
| Yorkshirian
|
5 May 2008
|
Incivility/Edit-warring
|
MRSC, Jza84
|
Proceeded to arbitration.
|
| Guido den Broeder
|
30 Apr 2008
|
Disruption of Wikipedia via COI and EL violations and wikilawyering
|
Fram, Scarian
|
Guido den Broeder blocked for 48 hours by Davidruben.
|
| Femmina
|
27 Apr 2008
|
Disruptive NPOV edits on iPhone
|
Atama, Phooto
|
Delisted due to inactivity. No response, no outside views.
|
| Justinm1978
|
27 Apr 2008
|
Disruption of Wikipedia via POV pushing and disregard for consensus.
|
Miranda, Allstarecho
|
Consensus to dismiss as premature.
|
| Wageslave
|
24 Apr 2008
|
Disruptive NPOV edits on several articles.
|
Frvernchanezzz, John.n-IRL
|
Wageslave stopped editing on 15 May 2008.
|
| Ed Fitzgerald
|
22 Apr 2008
|
Disregard for consensus, primarily regarding formatting/style.
|
Clarityfiend, Tagishsimon
|
Mixed responses and outside views; delisted due to inactivity.
|
| Cebactokpatop
|
16 Apr 2008
|
Tendentious edits, incivility, refusal to assume good faith and personal attacks by SPA on John Zizioulas page, leading to page protection and breakdown of informal mediation (twice).
|
Seminarist, Fr Lev
|
Delisted due to inactivity; no outside views.
|
| RobJ1981
|
14 Apr 2008
|
Harassment, WP:AGF, WP:CIVIL, WP:POINT and WP:OWN
|
McJeff, Angrymansr
|
RobJ1981 blocked for 1 month by Hesperian.
|
| Tango
|
13 Apr 2008
|
Questionable block of MONGO, pattern of poor judgement in use of certain admin tools
|
Nwwaew, Jehochman
|
Proceeded to arbitration
|
| Bardcom
|
2 Apr 2008
|
Persistent POV edits to remove geographic terminology he objects to.
|
Tb, Secisek
|
RFC-initiators formally agreed to avoid continuation of dispute and to close the RFC.
|
| Seeyou
|
27 Mar 2008
|
Incivility/Edit-warring/Accusations of sock-puppetry
|
Jéské Couriano, Ronz
|
Delisted due to inactivity; no outside views.
|
| Pedant17
|
11 Mar 2008
|
Edit-warring
|
RJC, BCST2001
|
Consensus to dismiss as premature and certifiers advised to attempt negotiation, Rfc on article content or mediation.
|
| 75.47.x.x
|
3 Mar 2008
|
Edit warring, incivility.
|
Evil saltine , NE2
|
RFC archived due to inactivity.
|
| JzG2
|
2 Mar 2008
|
Multiple violations of (editing, decorum, admin) policy
|
Cla68, Neil
|
Proceeded to arbitration
|
| WNDL42
|
28 Feb 2008
|
Incivility, disruptive editing, content disputes
|
Jefffire, Kww
|
Consensus to dismiss as premature and certifiers advised to attempt negotiation, Rfc on article content or mediation.
|
| DemolitionMan
|
26 Feb 2008
|
Persistent edit warring and disruption at Indian Rebellion of 1857
|
Ronnotel, Slatersteven
|
User topic banned on British Raj articles for 2 months per ANI thread
|
| IZAK
|
24 Feb 2008
|
Alleged violations of WP:CIVIL, WP:NPA, WP:AGF & WP:OWN
|
Bstone, Soxred93
|
RfC closed so that mediation may be attempted
|
| Skyring
|
22 Feb 2008
|
Tendentious editing.
|
Wm, Eyedubya
|
Delisted due to inactivity.
|
| Strider12
|
20 Feb 2008
|
Tendentious editing.
|
MastCell, Phyesalis
|
Proceeded to arbitration.
|
| 77.128.196.58
|
15 Feb 2008
|
IP range edit-warring against consensus.
|
Psantora, Data Fever
|
Delisted due to inactivity.
|
| Mantanmoreland
|
12 Feb 2008
|
Sockpuppetry.
|
SirFozzie, Durova
|
Proceeded to ArbCom; see final decision.
|
| Quizimodo
|
11 Feb 2008
|
Incivility.
|
Gazzster, GoodDay
|
Delisted due to inactivity. Conflict subsided after Quizimodo stopped editing on 13 February 2008.
|
| Skipsievert
|
9 Feb 2008
|
POV-pushing and not cooperating with other editors.
|
Isenhand , Luxaquitaine
|
Delisted due to inactivity.
|
| Cumulus Clouds
|
9 Feb 2008
|
Various disputed edits.
|
BQZip01, Johntex
|
Delisted due to inactivity.
|
| Archtransit
|
4 Feb 2008
|
Dispute with unblocks and blocks
|
Fut.Perf., Bellwether_BC
|
Achtransit was desysopped following evidence that he had been abusing multiple accounts, see ArbCom statement.
|
| Muscovite99
|
23 Jan 2008
|
Issues.
|
Frjohnwhiteford , Miyokan
|
Delisted due to inactivity.
|
| 81.9.61.227
|
23 Jan 2008
|
Revert-warring at Thelema article from multiple IPs.
|
Dan , Thiebes
|
Delisted due to inactivity.
|
| MPF
|
16 Jan 2008
|
Naming conflicts regarding plant common names.
|
Rkitko , MrDarwin
|
Delisted due to inactivity. Conflict subsided after MPF took an extended wikibreak.
|
| BigGabriel555
|
13 Jan 2008
|
tendentious editing, disruption, edit warring, WP:OWN
|
Pepemar2, SamEV
|
Issues settled through negotiation, apology and agreement.
|
| Fasach Nua
|
10 Jan 2008
|
Targeting images for deletion with faulty reasoning.
|
Edokter, Sceptre
|
Delisted due to inactivity.
|
| Whig 3
|
8 Jan 2008
|
Resumed problematic edits after indefblock overturned.
|
Vanished User, Filll
|
Dispute endorsed by some editors; RfC considered inappropriate/unnecessary by others.
|
| V-Dash
|
8 Jan 2008
|
Disruption, incivility, disregarding consensus.
|
Jéské Couriano, Friday
|
V-Dash was indefblocked by Friday on 14 January 2008 after continued disruption and incivility (block notice).
|
| R. fiend
|
5 Jan 2008
|
Repeated misuse of admin tools, dismissive and uncommunicative.
|
Alison, Steel359
|
Case moved to Arbitration and R.fiend resigned as an admin.
|
