Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Al Gore III (8th nomination)

This is a breakdown of the decision of Deleting the article Al Gore III based on the deletion discussion that happened at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Al Gore III (8th nomination)
Delete (br>

  1. Nominator User:Jerry. Coatrack
  2. User:TerriersFan agrees with nom, cites notability concerns
  3. User:PC78. No independent notability, compares article to tabloid
  4. User:BusterD, basically citing BLP concerns and "partisan bitterness"
  5. User:TenPoundHammer coatrack, notability
  6. User:Brewcrewer delete (and merge)
  7. User:Metropolitan90 doesn't qualify under WP:BIO. Also redirect.
  8. User:Bobby1011 (handschuh) Delete per nom
  9. User:Itub notability
  10. User:Utgard Loki, notability
  11. User:Undead warrior (Undeath) Notability not inherited
  12. User:EJF felony != notability (tabloid, or "yellow press" issue
  13. User:Bellhalla notability not inherited
  14. User:Calton Coatrack + non notable + not inherited
  15. User:Terraxos Notability not inherited, BLP concerns. (also redirect)
  16. User:Cumulus Clouds Not inherited
  17. User:Seicer Coatrack
  18. User:Mr.Z-man Notability not inherited, BLP concerns "per Terraxos"
  19. User:Addhoc lack of coverage in sources
  20. User:Mrprada911 per WP:ATTACK, BLP issue
  21. User:rewinn notability issue (in a humorous way)
  22. User:Sceptre (Will) Not inherited ("per Cumulus Clouds")
  23. User:Hit bull, win steak per previous afds; per "not inherited"

Keep

  1. User:Robert K S Notable because of family, popular culture references, not a coatrack, NPOV ("butt of late-night jokes", etc)
  2. User:Otto4711 citing 7 previous noms as enough evidence to keep on 8th nom ("enough is enough already")
  3. User:Mandsford citing prior consensus, adding "give it up already"
  4. User:Richard Arthur Norton (1958- ) "Same as before" (citing prior nominations)
  5. User:Boomgaylove keep because of "nationwide news coverage" and because Marijuana is cool and adderall isn't
  6. User:Alansohn, adequate sourcing exists, also citing 7 previous noms
  7. User:Colonel Warden "Evidently notable" with a borderline (brief mention) new source
  8. User:JamesMLane notability is inherited (in some cases)
  9. User:JoshuaZ (weak) keep citing previous noms; news coverage
  10. User:Crotalus horridus Keep, but rename
  11. User:BQZip01 per WP:NOTE, cites 7 previous noms as editors don't change their minds

Other

  1. User:TJ Spyke No opinion (and merge/redirect if deleted)
  2. User:Brinlong Merge to Al Gore
  3. Other comments came up about merging/redirecting to Al Gore and the dangers/problems with doing so based on Jeb Bush, Jr. redirecting to Jeb Bush