Wikipedia talk:Policies and guidelines/FAQ
I can't find proof that this guideline was adopted as an Official True™ Guideline through the
WP:PROPOSAL
process. Does that mean it's not legitimate?
The
WP:PROPOSAL
process itself was adopted in late 2008. It was based on the processes used for
Wikipedia:Identifying reliable sources (medicine)
and
Wikipedia:Manual of Style/Medicine-related articles
. Pages tagged as guidelines or policies before 2008 generally did not follow any consistent process. The older the page is, the more likely it was marked as a guideline or policy as a result of
off-wiki discussions
(especially in 2003 or earlier) or through a normal discussion on its talk page.